My opinion don't count for much mate because i have never really been a Fan of the type of game you like so i can not really comment apart from saying that if this was all that they released on consoles i would be doing a awful lot of fishing at night
Its clear to see mate you have a very high opinion of this type of game,nothing wrong with that as i love everything FPS which you don't like and again nothing wrong with that.
I do like certain types of games but the JRPG that attract your attention just put me of gaming mate if I'm honest,its probably because i have the attention span of a Gnat and find them utter confusing and boring.
Nothing bores me more than having to walk up to people in the open world and keep asking people questions and listening to storys that don't interest me or spending the first 30 minutes of a game designing my characters ,picking attributes and powers,shall i be a wizard or a genie or whatever,then spend another 15 minutes going through a endless list of changing the way i look .
Im not saying that the game you mention is like what but i have tried to play these Oblivion type games,Fallout,Elder Scrolls.Dragon Age and within a couple of hours i have marched back to the game shop and traded them and found myself asking the same question over and over…….Why oh why did i buy that when i know i don't like these type of games,but when i see rave reviews i think to myself i got to try that it must be good if everybody raving about it,Mass effect another prime example ,enjoyed it for the first 30 minutes then got totally bored……Sorry its just the way i am and thats why as individuals we all like different things,some like the same type and some don't .