Yes, you should be paying Infinity 1 rates.
Is it due to crosstalk? Or is it the attenuation?
What estimate does www.dslchecker.bt.com give for your line?
On first connection it was 44.3mb, so I signed up for infinity 2. Now it is 39.3mb. Not worth the extra cost. I must not be unique, there must be others whose connection speeds have reduced to around infinity 1 levels and yet are being charged infinity 2.