There is a list of devices approved by Openreach and the HH5A isn't on it, which speaks volumes.

Link?

You will also know that Plusnet have only recently adopted the HH5A for their own fibre service as well which they wouldn't have done if it wasn't fit for purpose.

Edited by gt94sss2 (Sun 24-Jan-16 14:42:38)

I'm not saying the HH5A or the Hub one isn't fit for purpose, mine is very stable. It's just that they don't support G.INP.

If they did, I'm sure some enterprising user or supplier would be very eager to provide evidence - which is so far, non-existent.

For example: the Huawei HG612 can be shown to have G.INP active and working. Similarly, the ECI modem can be shown to not have G.INP, for it to be inactive. Further the ECI modem can have modified firmware that will activate G.INP.

None of this is possible with the HH5A so it is impossible to be shown to have G.INP active and working.

In reply to a post by BatBoy:

There is a list of devices approved by Openreach and the HH5A isn't on it, which speaks volumes.

Evidence?

It seems so.

NO! Where is it....

You've provided no links to any evidence and to be fair no other user or forum has mentioned any other such evidence so I think you might be talking .........

That's what I'm saying - without any evidence it's all just opinion. What I want is proof.

Your saying you have documentation from Openreach not listing the HH5a. however you haven't provided a link and I you haven't said if the HH5b was listed?

As far as I'm concerned the HH5B supports G.INP. It's wireless throughput is very poor though, so between the two I prefer the HH5A - until my connection starts playing up.

LMAO... That's Nice....