General Discussion
  >> General Broadband Chatter


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.


Pages in this thread: 1 | 2 | (show all)   Print Thread
Standard User WhizzKidUK
(newbie) Thu 05-Nov-26 17:40:58
Print Post

Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[link to this post]
 
OpenReach are now offering FTTP for me 🥳
I have 3 months until my OneStream FTTC contract ends. They cannot offer what EE will, so I am choosing to switch early.
I know OneStream early termination fees are 'interesting'.
They want ~£300 from me.
It would be far cheaper just to let the contract run.

Can anyone see any technical issue with letting the contract run until termination and cancelling once over?
EE's contribution towards fees would be £200. But I assume it won't actually be £200 of that.

All advice considered helpful!
Standard User DFScale
(experienced) Thu 05-Nov-26 18:55:42
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
Order NEW fttp from your chosen supplier. Don't have your new supplier replace the old fttc. Cancel the fttc for the end of the contract. You might lose the contract buyout, but if it is cheaper to continue the old contact than buy it out, this is the way to go unless you can bear waiting until the end of your contract.
Standard User WhizzKidUK
(newbie) Thu 05-Nov-26 19:46:38
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: DFScale] [link to this post]
 
That is my exact plan. I agree!

But it's not about the semantics/logistics, the question is, is there any technical reason why I can't have the FTTC supply running at the same time as the FTTP? Will there be any issues with my service provision?


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.

Standard User Pheasant
(eat-sleep-adslguide) Thu 05-Nov-26 20:07:53
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
There is absolutely no problem with doing that, technically or commercially.

Some folks deliberately keep this type of setup specifically for various reasons. Just remember to cancel the FTTC once the contract is up.
Standard User tdw42
(committed) Thu 05-Nov-26 20:16:33
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
There should not be, as the two services are completely separate physical connections to the premises.

However a number of people have had issues where the installer has cut the existing FTTC copper cable and used it to pull in the new fibre service where the route involves an overhead connection across a road or an underground connection through a tight duct. Just make sure on the day the installer is made aware that the new connection is an additional, not replacement, one.
Standard User clyde123
(committed) Fri 06-Nov-26 08:03:07
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
I have done exactly that a number of times this year, albeit for business premises.

Make sure you write something like "this is a new ADDITIONAL service" into the notes section of any order, or any other communications you have with the new FTTP provider.
Do not use the switching service.
Standard User MHC
(sensei) Fri 06-Nov-26 10:16:05
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
Have you asked them for an EXACT breakdown of that fee?


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

M H C


taurus excreta cerebrum vincit
Standard User jpm
(fountain of knowledge) Fri 06-Nov-26 12:00:09
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
If you aren't paying over £100 a month then that ETF would not meet Ofcom's requirements of fair terms. ETFs should also reflect any reduction in costs of the CP not having to provide the service.
Standard User Iniltous
(committed) Fri 06-Nov-26 12:06:22
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: MHC] [link to this post]
 
Onestream have a somewhat dubious reputation for some things , as far as early termination charges , outwardly it’s not that unreasonable, £17 for each incomplete month of the minimum term , so 3x£17 , £51 , but the way the inflate this figure smacks of sharp practice, the ‘free installation’ offered at the start , is only free if you see out the minimum term , so they add upto £125 for that , they then charge for the non return of the router (even though they haven’t asked for it back yet ) it’s upto £125 for that as well , they say they will refund that once the router is back in their possession, but that is how they get to the £300 figure.

Edited by Iniltous (Fri 06-Nov-26 12:07:30)

Standard User WhizzKidUK
(newbie) Fri 06-Nov-26 13:52:31
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: Iniltous] [link to this post]
 
Yes.
£17 per month left.
£100 activation fee discount I had
£125 for the router they don't want back but the T&Cs say that I will never own.

The T&Cs are about to go through my AI legal friend's eyes!

Thanks all for the really helpful advice.
Standard User MHC
(sensei) Fri 06-Nov-26 14:39:49
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
Maybe some negotiation with EE. Explain the ridiculous early termination fees - although with lead times for OR it could now be shorter, and then ask if EE will give you a monthly discount rather than a contribution to the early termination. If you get the right agent - it could be of benefit.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

M H C


taurus excreta cerebrum vincit
Standard User candlerb
(knowledge is power) Fri 06-Nov-26 17:29:34
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: tdw42] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by tdw42:
There should not be, as the two services are completely separate physical connections to the premises.

However a number of people have had issues where the installer has cut the existing FTTC copper cable and used it to pull in the new fibre service where the route involves an overhead connection across a road or an underground connection through a tight duct. Just make sure on the day the installer is made aware that the new connection is an additional, not replacement, one.

Which of course, doesn't matter if the FTTC service isn't being used. It's nice to have a dual redundant service though: I kept FTTC for a while after getting FTTP.

Check your T&Cs and make sure to diarise the day you need to call your FTTC provider to give termination notice: if you're not migrating to another provider, but ceasing, then they may insist on (say) 30 days notice even when you're out of contract. So give notice before end of contract, choosing a cessation date one day past the contract period.

Also beware that some service providers charge a cease fee for lines which are not migrated to another service provider. This is a cost raised onto them and they may choose to pass it on to you. (There was talk about Openreach getting rid of this charge, but I'm not sure if BTW still charge it)
Standard User merrymouse
(learned) Mon 09-Nov-26 11:12:25
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
Be very afraid when they come to fit fibre. i ordered fibre with EE online I was with BT at the time. I wanted to keep FTTC till fibre was fitted so I could port my landline number to AA. Mr QUINN arrived and the first thing he did was pull all the copper from the pole out. I told him I was still paying for FTTC and it was not cancelled.He said this has to be done with all new fibre connections. Did he listen did he hell, said it was policy to rip copper out and I would have a working phone before he left. Complete lies as I had not ordered a phone, also only tried connection on his phone not my computor plus did not connect router to computor, which EE said he would be set up. Took a couple of days to get sorted and number ported to AA. This was all done by EE so a massive shout out to them for sorting it, which at first they said could not be done.
Standard User binary
(committed) Wed 11-Nov-26 09:43:07
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: candlerb] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by candlerb:
In reply to a post by tdw42:
There should not be, as the two services are completely separate physical connections to the premises.

However a number of people have had issues where the installer has cut the existing FTTC copper cable and used it to pull in the new fibre service where the route involves an overhead connection across a road or an underground connection through a tight duct. Just make sure on the day the installer is made aware that the new connection is an additional, not replacement, one.

Which of course, doesn't matter if the FTTC service isn't being used. It's nice to have a dual redundant service though: I kept FTTC for a while after getting FTTP.

Check your T&Cs and make sure to diarise the day you need to call your FTTC provider to give termination notice: if you're not migrating to another provider, but ceasing, then they may insist on (say) 30 days notice even when you're out of contract. So give notice before end of contract, choosing a cessation date one day past the contract period.

Also beware that some service providers charge a cease fee for lines which are not migrated to another service provider. This is a cost raised onto them and they may choose to pass it on to you. (There was talk about Openreach getting rid of this charge, but I'm not sure if BTW still charge it)


This - if the OP doesn't need the old Onestream FTTC service, then even if the FTTP installer cuts and removes the copper cabling then that would make zero contractual difference regarding the old Onestream FTTC service. All the OP needs to do is to serve notice to Onestream at the appropriate time that they wish to cancel their FTTC service.

Re Onestream - essentially if you carefully adhere to their T&Cs then they can be a cheap option. But make sure you'll be able to see the minimum term of a contract out with them before you sign up - e.g. there's no possibility of moving house during that time. And use your own router - don't rent one of theirs!

(I wouldn't go with an FTTP install with them, as if there were any complications you'd be at the mercy of having to deal with their customer services. That said, I'm sure I recall reading of someone having a positive FTTP installation experience with them where there was some sort of hiccup and their CS actually were helpful in liaising with Openreach...)
Standard User WhizzKidUK
(newbie) Thu 19-Nov-26 13:42:34
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: binary] [link to this post]
 
So here we are with the latest update. One stream are absolutely adamant that they want £292 for the remaining three months. The breakdown on this is the equipment charge, the payment of the set up fee which I never had to pay, and what seems to be four months remaining rental.
The rental piece is interesting to start with as obviously I have been paying for my rental upfront and so they are trying to charge me twice for a remaining month.
The keeping the FTTC as well as the FTTP seems to be impossible after discussion so I can’t explore that avenue.
So my plan is to have the FTTP installed. In regards to the fees I have already lodged a complaint about this worded thus:

Dear Complaints Team,

I am writing to dispute the early termination fee of £292 on my account.

On 25 October 2026 I gave notice to end my contract on 23 November 2026. My minimum term ends on 23 February 2027. Under clause 10.4.2 of your Terms and Conditions, the contract ends 30 days after notice, so no more than 3 months of the minimum term remain. Your Price Guide (page 13) calculates the fee by multiplying the monthly termination fee by the months remaining. No combination of charges in your Price Guide reaches £292 over 3 months. £292 is only possible with 4 months, which suggests the period was counted from the date I gave notice. I am already paying for the notice period through my normal bill, so this charges me twice for the same month.

I also dispute two further charges:

1. Router, £125. Clause 9.3.5 says the router is rented and always remains Onestream's property. I will return it once my service ends. Charging the full price for equipment that comes back to you does not compensate you for any loss.

2. Activation, £99. Clauses 9.4.5 and 14.1.2 say you "may" charge this, excluding discounts, while clause 4.3.5 says you "will". Under section 69 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, where a term can be read more than one way, the reading most favourable to the consumer applies.

Please:
- send an itemised breakdown of the £292, including the start and end dates used;
- correct the remaining term to 3 months;
- remove the router and activation charges;
- confirm which returns address to use, since clauses 9.3.6 and 11.2 give different addresses.

Once I receive the corrected bill, I will pay the time-based part of the fee for 3 months. If this cannot be resolved, I will refer the matter to CISAS after 6 weeks, or sooner if you issue a deadlock letter.

Yours faithfully,
Standard User Iniltous
(committed) Thu 19-Nov-26 14:10:00
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
It’s not clear why you think getting FTTP installed independently of the FTTC service isn’t possible , having both for the remaining term with Onestream and then cancelling that without any early termination fees (although they will still try in the non return of the router charge and then supposedly refund that ) may be the path of least resistance, all you need is your FTTP provider to proceed with your installation without using the switching service OTS , this would be the same process if you were moving into a vacant property for example where no existing provider exists.

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/categories/phon...
There are plenty of posts on here about Onestream , including some that have tried the same strategy of challenging the legality of their termination charges.
Standard User candlerb
(knowledge is power) Thu 19-Nov-26 14:14:03
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: Iniltous] [link to this post]
 
Exactly this. Leave it to run for the remaining 3 months, while you get FTTP installed from a different provider.

If you end up paying for 1 or 2 months after the end of the contract, chalk this up to experience. Add OneStream into the "never again" pile, and tell all your friends and social media never to use them either.
Standard User WhizzKidUK
(newbie) Thu 19-Nov-26 14:35:17
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: Pheasant] [link to this post]
 
Simply because EE said can’t/wont. I did ask.
Standard User DFScale
(experienced) Thu 19-Nov-26 20:15:50
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: WhizzKidUK] [link to this post]
 
OK, if being bought out by the gaining ISP is important to you, then use the switching service.

But if you want the FTTP concurrent with the FTTC, then find an ISP who will accommodate this. Many will.
Standard User WhizzKidUK
(newbie) Thu 19-Nov-26 20:54:02
Print Post

Re: Keep old ISP with FTTC to FTTP switch to avoid fees?


[re: DFScale] [link to this post]
 
Only one supplier will offer 1.6Gbps. So I went with them. That’s the only reason.
Pages in this thread: 1 | 2 | (show all)   Print Thread

Jump to