|
|
|
Hi, can someone please explain to me about this "ADSL2+" and the modem chipset "problem" that seems to be happening.
DEMON (who are owned by Cable and Wireless) have upgraded me and had 1464 PP connections of which only 21 got through in a day... (meaning most of the day i was offline).
Many Thanks
Ashley
|
|
|
I suggest that there is no reply because what you have quoted does not look to make sence.
These things should just work.
Ask the support team for a proper reason/explanation and post that to this board.
IanD
|
|
|
|
I have been innformed when BT / other hardware suppliers have upgraded there DSLAM to ADSL2+ that not all are compliant to all Modem chipsets resulting in very flakey ADSL login / staying connected.
So in a day my router submitted 1464 PPP login attempts, of which only 21 actually where accepted, these 21 evidently got booted resulting in the many attempts to login.
This is not cable / hardware issues it was only after being upgraded to ADSL2+ from Demon (they have a number of super strong worded emails with SYSLOG files enclosed), i have backed down to a 8 year old ADSL 3com box which seems way more reliable to login failures, still in the 100's area of PPP login attemps but remains logged in way longer.
Nothing changed my end, 3 hardware tested all the same only AFTER the ADSL2+ upgrade from my ISP (Demon who are now owned by Cable and Wireless).
Many Thanks
|
|
Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.
|
|
|
I have been innformed when BT / other hardware suppliers have upgraded there DSLAM to ADSL2+ that not all are compliant to all Modem chipsets resulting in very flakey ADSL login / staying connected. Did they by any chance mention that they had a special offer on modems?
Sigh.
It's true that some chipset/DSLAM combinations work better than others but unless you're on a poor line it rarely matters. ADSL is a standard and all chips support the important bits. In some cases a specific chipset can use a manufacturer specific feature to get a bit more speed but I don't think many ISPs enable those features. It's probably too much hassle for the their support personnell and can also lead to accusations of unfair service toward owners of other modems.
Andrue Cope
[Brackley, UK
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rP1q5ierKVQ - just because :)]
Edited by Andrue (Mon 27-Apr-09 08:01:59)
|
|
|
I suspect you have the same problems as described in - http://forums.thinkbroadband.com/general/f/3624537-p... which is a Demon ADSL2+ upgrade followed by auth failures.
I suggested getting Demon to confirm the required login credentials. MrS saig that VPI/VCI settings could have changed. I didn't realise that would allow sync but block login and suspect that is the correct disgnosis.
Either way call Demon and tell them you can't login so would they confirm what you need to set in the router.
If you can't fix it with a hammer you've got an electrical problem.
|
|
|
Addendum:Actually I might not be entirely correct. I have come across a few people claiming compatibility issues. I'll revise my statement to:
"Incompatibilities are not unknown but are unusual. They probably occur with very old modems or very new DSLAMS"
I would expect that as long as you bought a recent well known brand from your local PC World or equivalent you'd have no problems. IOW - if you want to replace your router you should be fine with whatever you fancy.
Andrue Cope
[Brackley, UK
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rP1q5ierKVQ - just because :)]
Edited by Andrue (Mon 27-Apr-09 10:50:07)
|
|
|
Did they by any chance mention that they had a special offer on modems?
Sigh.
lol, no, however we havnt got that far down the road yet
|
|
|
I would expect that as long as you bought a recent well known brand from your local PC World or equivalent you'd have no problems.
Interestingly, the one in now is a 3COM 812 router (no problems before, however has issues now).
AND 2 3COM 200 series, both firmware 3.0.1, also no problems before however has problems now (after there upograde).
Many Thanks
|
|
|
When buying kit you also need to ensure it has the best firmware on it, this is not always the latest, so do look around to see what others are using.
C&W has had some issues, Virgin.net customers have also had similar issues, and this seems more common that it does with other providers using ADSL2+, i.e. it may be down to how they configure their connections, or their authentication server has a very short timeout perhaps.
|
|
The author of the above post is a thinkbroadband staff member. It may not constitute an official statement on behalf of thinkbroadband.
|
|
|
it seems with adsl2/+ chipset compatability is more important and I think its because manufacturers have done much less compatability testing than with adsl1.
Best chipset really depends on which isp you on.
ukonline/sky best is connexant/globespan typically billion routers.
be/o2 best is broadcom typically speedtouch/netgear dg834GT
BT 21CN isps, no idea what the best is and what chipset the dslams use.
again with c&w no idea what chipset.
Edited by Chrysalis (Thu 30-Apr-09 04:47:27)
|
|
|
My Linksys WAG54GS stopped working immediately my line switched to ADSL2+ no matter what I or Linksys tried to get it working. The problem is now with their engineers who are writing a new driver.
Initially I put an ancient D-Link on the line and got things up and running again, now I have a Netgear DG835G. A nasty piece of kit I shall dump as soon as Linksys do their biz. The Netgear router is fine for a one-person set-up but with two or more computers on-line it is a case of constantly tweaking the QoS settings so that one machine doesn't hog the whole bandwidth. It can only handle IPV4, it hates using static IPs for the LAN so that FTP traffic etc can be directed to the right machine, wireless network is weak as reported elsewhere�
moan moan moan, grumble.
Edited by deleted (Wed 20-May-09 11:03:36)
|