LLU or WBC

So I've seen that my local exchange will be upgraded to WBC ADSL2 soon, and I was wondering if I'm better sticking with a LLU provider?
I currently get a 15mb sync but a 4-5mb throughput on a my llu line

Sounds bad. Which LLU ISP, and line stats please?

(WBC is ADSL2+ . ADSL2 has a maximum sync of 12Mbps.)

Sorry, It was as typo, it should be ADSL2+
I'm with vivaciti on there Variety package.
I'll dig up the current stats tonight as I've got a new router:
My stats were with a DG848PN with the DGteam FW (taken from a support ticket 4/4 last year):
Down Up
SNR (dB): 8.2 7.6
Attn(dB): 31.5 13.0
Pwr(dBm): 19.3 12.1
Max(Kbps): 15916 1208
And they are now with a DGND3300
ADSL Link Downstream Upstream
Connection Speed 14883 kbps 1022 kbps
Line Attenuation 31.0 db 17.1 db
Noise Margin 6.2 db 11.1 db
Rate (Kbps): 12773 1021
Dan

Edited by deleted (Wed 25-Jan-12 19:35:31)

I would say LLU should be able to provide better than 21CN/WBC. That is because LLU doesn't have the BT profiling system. However, depends on what package you are on with Vivaciti as your rates seem a little low. I have just moved to one of the Vivaciti Be wholesale packages which is giving me an excellent connection on a high attenuation than you have. It may be that Variety is not quite such a good LLU network (don't know much about the other packages I'm afraid).

I do have a feeling my account is messed up as out of hours there is not supposed to be any throttling our of hours.
Xilo have just started to offer something at my exchange so Im currently thinking of moving, but saw WBC is coming soon.

Do you have Be wholesale at the exchange? Moving to either Xilo or Vivaciti using the Be network both seem like good options at the moment (but then I would say that having gone live on Vivaciti yesterday). Only reason I didn't go Xilo was the £40 connection fee otherwise I would most likely have ended up there (just biding my time until FTTC dates are properly announced for my exchange).

No just sky and talktalk . The migration fee is annoying but it may be worth it .
There is no way we will get any fiber as were just a small ish village

What is you're exchange name, as having 2 llu suppliers shows that theres a commerical investment into that exchange.
Exchange may be in the commercial rollout or it could be enabled with BDUK funds (BT is likely to win the maority).

Its Audley .
I wouldn't expect it - the local city on has a 'this year' date for FTTC

Are you connecting wired or wireless to your router?

If wireless, at a time when the throughput is bad try wired. Just to make sure it isn't the wirelss that is screwing you. It often is .

Your stats are fine.