TalkTalk 'special offer' fibre vs Plusnet standard price

Am I missing somethng?
Am looking to switch to FTTC, which may give us the dizzily fast speed of 5Mb (where's the sarky icon?).
Anyway, at present I'm out of contract with TalkTalk on an evening and weekend phone deal plus broaband LLU, they are offering me a 'special offer' of £5 extra for 6 months then rising to £15 extra for rest of term, this makes it £31.70 inc. for 6 months then going up to £41.70!
Looking at Plusnet, they have no special offers on fibre+evenings and weekends phone, but their standard price appears to be £30.94 inc., if this is correct Plusnet are hands down winners, or is there something i've overlooked?

Plusnet have significant cashback, check out their current offer at http://www.quidco.com/

In reply to a post by Spud2003:

Plusnet have significant cashback, check out their current offer at http://www.quidco.com/

This would seem to be an extra £75 back to me, on top of saving £10 month for most of the contract, it all seems too good to be true, I still keep thinking there must be some catch I'm missing.

No Catch, just a lot of leg work on your part to get your cashback.

Watch out for the 38/20 product withdrawal from today. The new one is 38/2. As of course is TalkTalk. I haven't checked the price or offers/cashbacks.

Edited by RobertoS (Wed 17-Jun-15 11:03:40)

Take a look at EE prices...

FTTC Broadband speeds up to 38Mb/sec with Anytime mobile calls, Anytime UK landline calls, £9.95 a month for 6 months then £24.95 a month. Pay monthly (18 months) All plans subject to line rental at £16.40 a month.

https://broadband.ee.co.uk/home.do

Wow! I might go for it myself at that price, although I pay £19.50 per month for ADSL2+ broadband unlimited with weekend and evenings UK landline calls, the price including line rental.

Edited by deleted (Wed 17-Jun-15 13:19:39)

And today Plusnet have added a small sweetner, £5/month discount for first 6 months, over the course of 18 month contract this comes to around £150 saving even without the cashback compared to staying with TalkTalk.
Why I find it odd is that for many years I've been a Tiscali/TalkTalk customer and they have always offered me a deal which made it not worth changing to another provider, but now they seem to have lost the plot.

In reply to a post by burble:

This would seem to be an extra £75 back to me, on top of saving £10 month for most of the contract, it all seems too good to be true, I still keep thinking there must be some catch I'm missing.

No catch. I signed up with Plusnet about a month ago, using Topcashback(like Quidco). The cashback was about £90 - the cashback has already been paid into my bank. Before that I also used cashback with TalkTalk, again no problems.

Post deleted by MrSaffron