Essentially we've gained 5-6Mbit download at the expense of about 2Mbit upload speed.
Might this be a new profile for the service as a whole using different frequencies? I'm not too worried at losing a bit of upload for better download.
I just posted about this on the Fibre forum, but essentially the answer is yes: new profile *and* different frequencies.
BT's switch to profile 17a also seems to include a switch from bandplan 997 to bandplan 998.
The differences are that:
- In the existing frequencies (under 7MHz), around 0.6MHz is swapped from upstream to downstream
- The first 1.5MHz of the new frequency allocation (above 7MHz) is given to downstream; if they stuck with 997, it would have gone to upstream.
Your experience suggests you've experienced changes because of both parts, but that you then haven't gained much from the additional upstream (8.5MHz - 12MHz) or the higher downstream (12MHz - 17MHz)