The thing with ADSL seemed to be that somehow uploading was more "damaging" to the connection, such that games would lag out, websites would take ages to load etc. Whilst maxing out the download rate didn't really do anything. Never completely understood why, but thought it was something to do with the asynchronous nature of the technology. That uploading is kind of... "more difficult", for lack of a less ridiculous way to put it.There's various effects in play. The slower line speed on ADSL than FTTC means it takes proportionately longer to transmit each packet, even on an idle line, also many ADSL connections are highly asymmetric - I had 16/1 Mbit/s when I was on ADSL2+. These effects combine sometimes to delay an ACK beyond the point where TCP assumes a packet has been lost. Once the packet is assumed lost, TCP backs off sending assuming there is packet loss and retransmits the unACKed packet (selective retransmission now being ubiquitous).
The relatively slow ADSL upstream is fairly easy to drive to saturation without careful management by the router.
Not only is FTTC typically much faster and therefore of higher bandwidth, FTTC in the UK is typically rather less asymmetric (4:1 to 6:1 seems typical) than UK ADSL, which also helps.
You may find it interesting to monitor your connection using Wireshark.



Pages in this thread:
Print Thread
deleted