Horses for courses I guess. I loved TLOU and I mean really enjoyed it. Games like that are better described as experiences and that's what a campaign is all about to me.
As for GTAV, I love that too, but not for it's ability to move me or make me think about what I'm doing. Just because it has made me world famous for dicking around! I'm sure the story is good fun, but I'm not big on campaigns in open worlds. I always seem to get waylaid whilst getting to where I'm supposed to be going, so after I reached Michael, I just cut out the middle man and started dicking around all of the time, lol!
But the difference is as "Band of Brothers" to "Dad's Army". They're not supposed to compare.