In reply to a post by Anonymous:

http://www.samknows.com/broadband/exchange/LCROC

i have plugged into the test socket and now stats are

ADSL Link Downstream Upstream
Connection Speed 15775 kbps 987 kbps
Line Attenuation 17.0 db 6.5 db
Noise Margin 12.1 db 13.1 db

the throughput speed is not very good at all. im using a wired connection.
can talktalk capped my throughput speed?? because thats what looks likes happening. http://www.speedtest.net/result/1493113872.png

thanks

ps i h8 talktalk

No real difference there then, so the home phone wiring isn't affecting things. You don't use a plug-in phone extension cable between the socket and router though do you?

TalkTalk throttle P2P heavily. Anything else should be fine. That speed test is very poor though, as you say!

no extension cable at all and no sky tv on my line. i also changed my filter but no change. Think im going to sign up too plusnet im sure they are better then talktalk n im sure i will get more then 15meg with them. i think talktalk are just messing me about with my line speed. is it true that plusnet have all uk based call centres?

You need to check your exchange with the link I gave you. That will tell us whether Plusnet can give you up to 24Mbps or only up to 8Mbps.

my exchange is rochdale

Right - yes, Plusnet will connect you at similar speeds to TalkTalk, as the exchange is WBC-enabled. (Up to 24Mbps).

However, do you do a lot of P2P/torrents? Plusnet traffic shape a lot, see the tables on this page.

You have several other good ISPs there as well, and some of them don't throttle or traffic shape.

Is your phone with Tiscali/TalkTalk as well?

How much are you paying, and does that include the phone line rental?

yes i have everything with talktalk. im on the plus package. paying 14.99plus 13.80 line rental. i do alil p2p but not much. talktalk have traffic management but only download from p2p if i need to in the day time.

thanks

I gave you some garbage in my previous post. Plusnet, and most other ISPs, will connect you faster than 15Mbps that you have from TalkTalk, and I would expect the throughput speed to be better if you don't hit traffic management.

So I suggest you try Plusnet Extra, and if you find the traffic management gets to you then add the Pro option to get rid of it.

You might find Plusnet costs a bit more than TalkTalk.

I think you will need a "SIMultaneous Provide", as if your line is TalkTalk LLU which it sounds like it has to be taken back off them, and without a SIM provide that could leave you with no broadband for 2-3 weeks. I suggest you register on these forums, then you can post in the Plusnet one and ask other users what they think. Also, more importantly, you would be able to PM bpullen who is a great Plusnet Rep on here, and ask him to organise the SIM Provide, as they often go wrong.

thanks very much. going too sign up tho the website now. it dont seem to ask 4 a mac code? soon as im live will post my new stats thanks Roberto you been very helpfull

One thing i noted from the supplied stats is the high 12db magins set by tt on a short line for heavens sake, i would see if you can get them to lower it to at least the default of 6db and try fast path as well, then you could see 21-22mbits sync, + you would see the full 24 mbit sync at a 3db margin fast path, maybe worth your time to join their tt users forum and ask for the profile changes to be made to your line config, before jumping ship, don't try going though their useless tech support on the phone they don't have a clue and don't give a dam,

One thing to consider with plus net or any other isp who resells a bt product, is it would be subject to the bt dlm and also the stupid lower than you can get profiling system ,

Could of gotten a profile change on the TT forums.