Then, probably, methinks, you have 2 separate issues. 1] you might have a broken router 2] you have a some kind of a pc setup problem with your modem. Don't forget, when you cahnge from ethernet to modem, you are using a different network interface, for which any firewall amy be differently setup.
Depends now what you want to do. Do you want to change to using the modem? Or do you want to fix or replace the router - ie the modem is just for diagnostics while you fix the router? If it is the latter, it might not be worth the fight with the modem.
And how are you accessing the internet now? Are you on dialup on the same pc?
=======================================
Everything below the line above is my sig
[Notice: Private mail is turned on, but anything received by these means can and will be published]