|
|
Are PlusNet still actively moving existing customers from 20CN to 21CN ?
If so, do they stil send email to warn of the impending change?
This morning, I lost my broadband connectiion for around 2 minutes and when it came back, I noticed I had been switched from an Alcatel DSLAM to a Texas Instruments MSAN, connecting using ADSL1.
(I'm on the old BBYW package)
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
Poopex (03-08)->o2 LLU (08-)
|
|
|
|
Yes to both questions.
20CN uses DSLAMs and 21CN uses MSANs so it does sound like you've been moved over. If you PM me your Plusnet username, I can check for you.
|
|
|
tnx for confirming.
I just realised I haven't been receiving the monthly direct debit notification emails too.
Looked in spam folder in my google mail account and several emails from Plusnet are present including one notifying me of the 21CN migration.
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
Poopex (03-08)->o2 LLU (08-)
|
|
Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.
|
|
|
Are PlusNet still actively moving existing customers from 20CN to 21CN ?
AFAIK it's cheaper for PN to use the 21CN network.
I'm sure it will be cheaper for other ISPs as well.
|
|
|
|
An opportune moment to ask - are all new customers with a 21CN enabled exchange automatically put on 21CN then?
Meldrew
|
|
|
|
Only on Extra / Pro.
|
|
|
|
Why
I was put on 21CN and I am on Value
I thought that one advantage of 21CN for Plusnet was reduced cost
|
|
|
|
We have bulk migrated some Value customers to 21CN. 21CN is indeed cheaper for us.
|
|
|
and it has improved my line as well
|
|
|
|
So some value customers are more valued than others? If it it cheaper for you then what is the problem with migrating them all?
Meldrew
|
|
|
I'm still happily on 20CN
Before changing routers 8 days ago I had 78 day uptime and, at 3km from exchange, get a 6000kbps profile.
|
|
|
I'm still happily on 20CN 
Before changing routers 8 days ago I had 78 day uptime and, at 3km from exchange, get a 6000kbps profile.
Sadly the switch to 21CN has not been good for me.
While I was connected to Alcatel DSLAM, my 2700HGV router had no trouble holding sync for up to a month at a time, with line sync around 5200-5700kbps. My IP profile has been consistent 4500kbps with 9db noise margin. My line has never been particularly stable. (48dB downstream attenuation)
Since moving onto TI MSAN around a week or so ago, the router has been losing sync at least once every 2 days. I noted the line sync had also gone up to around 6000kbps. ie. seems to be less stable.
The more frequent loss of sync would have been fine if it wasn't for the fact something happened this morning where over a dozen disconnects were observed around midnight. As a result, my target noise margin now appears to have been raised to 15dB and my best line sync has plummeted to 3700 to 4544kbps. My IP profile is surely going to nose dive.
I haven't raised a ticket with PlusNet yet.
Does anyone know whether the target noise margin will automatically fall from this 15dB figure, or am I now stuck with it? (I've had the 9db target noise margin figure ever since I joined Plusnet in 2008)
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
Poopex (03-08)->o2 LLU (08-)
Edited by bill888 (Sun 18-Jul-10 14:24:58)
|
|
|
@meldrew
Networks changes are done by the Networks Team, the only reasons they choose on are availability and capacity. There's no point in us changing over all of our customers to 21CN and then leaving bandwidth spare on 20CN.
@bill888
Sounds like we need to raise an intermittent connection fault for you, please visit http://faults.plus.net to do this. We can reset your target SNR margin once the fault is fixed.
|
|
|
@bill888
Sounds like we need to raise an intermittent connection fault for you, please visit http://faults.plus.net to do this. We can reset your target SNR margin once the fault is fixed.
I've been monitoring my connection last couple of days.
I have noticed I get far fewer errors reported by my router since the Target Noise margin is set to 15db resulting in lower 4500kbps sync speed.
I noticed late last night at 11pm, the current noise margin dipped from the target value of 15db to 11db.
Based on my observations, when I was connected to Alcatel DSLAM, a target margin of 9db seemed to be the optimal setting to give me reliable 5200-5700kbps connection (6db target previously led to frequent disconnects)
But I now perceive 9db to be too low since moving to TI MSAN on 21CN, as this gives me line speeds as high at 6000kbps which I perceive as unstable.
I don't believe there is an intermittent fault on my line. My line is not perfect.
Q. How easy would it be to just set my target Noise Margin to 12db, this should give me line sync speed over 5000 kbps thus hopefully restoring the status quo ?
The current 15db setting is too aggressive/safe resulting in sub 4500kbps line speeds for me at the moment.
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
Poopex (03-08)->o2 LLU (08-)
|
|
|
|
The line will naturally train in at the correct value. If we set it to 12dB (which can only be done via raising a fault and calling our suppliers) then it will only change when DLM wants it to.
|
|
|
Edit - Just realised, I'm assuming you have been moved onto ADSLs+ as part of the switch. If you are on the 21CN system but with an ADSL Max profile then I'm probably talking rot below.
A better solution on lines of this length if you can achieve it with your router, or if Plusnet will set it for you, is to use ADSL2 rather than ADSL2+.
ADSL2 is inherently more stable than ADSL2+ because it doesn't use the higher frequencies which can give trouble. You also get about 3dB lower attenuation for the same reason. The same frequencies and attenuation that you had on ADSL Max, just better utilised.
Many of us on O2 LLU find we gain both stability and a small amount of speed by doing this.
My broadband basic info/help site - www.robertos.me.uk
My domains,website and mail hosting - Tsohost. Internet connection - O2 Standard.
Edited by RobertoS (Mon 19-Jul-10 17:56:25)
|
|
|
I'm still on ADSL1 (ADSL Max).
I'll give it a week to prove the line is stable. Then I'll try a manual resync. If there is no change to the presently high target noise margin of 15db, then I'll raise a fault ticket to see if we can get it lowered to 12db.
According to BT speedtester, I think my IP profile is now 3291k (was 4500k)
(Downstream line attenuation unchanged from 20CN, at around 48.4db according to my router.)
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
Poopex (03-08)->o2 LLU (08-)
|
|
|
|
Mine jumped 3dB when moving from 20CN to 21CN and hasn't dropped since.
I did a fair bit of experimenting after the 10 day so-called training period had passed and found that I could drive the speed up to 4256kbps noise margin 6.9dB but then dropped it back to 4,000kbps (3,500 IP profile) but under certain weather conditions the error rate went very high so I lowered to about 3,600kbps (3,000 IP profile) by pushing the noise margin down by about 1dB to 11dB and it has been absolutely stable
|
|
|
Line stable since last weekend. No change in target noise margin when I rebooted router. Still stuck at 15db. Raised a fault ticket this morning.
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
Edited by bill888 (Fri 23-Jul-10 15:51:47)
|
|
|
|
PM me your username and I'll take a look for you
|
|
|
PM sent.
Tnx in advance
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
|
|
|
|
I've replied to your ticket.
|
|
|
hi Ben
72 hours has passed, and there has been no loss of sync as I expected.
What happens next ?
Should I reboot my router and see whether the target noise margin drops from 15db ?
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
|
|
|
|
Your line has been nice and stable so give it a reboot and we'll see where we are afterwards
|
|
|
I've just resynced.
Line speed has dropped from 4302 kbps to 4032kbps with 15.9db noise margin.
There is a light shower outside.
Resynced again and speed is now 4224kbps with 15db noise margin.
It appears DLM is still insisting on applying a 15db target noise margin to my line.
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
|
|
|
|
We'll need to let the Faults Team have a good look at this one to see if we're getting any erroring on your 15dB SNR. They have your update on ticket 34377056 and will be in touch in due course.
|
|
|
|
My experience on 21CN (not ADSL2) is that the profiling system is much more aggressive.
When my line transferred the default noise margin immediately jumped from 9dB to 12dB.
After the so called 10 day period which did nothing I started fiddling with DMT and drove the noise margin down to 7dB which gave me a 4000kbps sync speed (3,500 IP profile) but I found that the error rate was too high at times so I trimmed it back to 11.5dB which gave me a sync of 3520kbps (3,000 IP profile) and everything was nice and stable for over a week. For no apparent reason - the error rate wasn't excessive - it bounced the default noise margin up to 15dB with a speed of 2,880.
Within under 20 minutes I spotted it and drove the noise margin back to 9dB and a speed of 3776 where is has remained for nearly 5 days.
For some reason the system didn't drop the IP profile for another 18 hours or so and hasn't yet increased it
|
|
|
At last, the Faults Team has put in a request to OpenReach to lower my target SNR to 12db earlier this evening, after conducting numerous tests.
Two hours later, I noticed my router resynced and Eureka, my SNR has fallen from 15db to my requested 12db.
The latest entry on the ticket advises my line has started a 10 day training period.
----------------------------------------------------------
Poopex (05-06)->NewNet (07-08)->PlusNet (08-)
|