Is there any backup data for this as I have a fairly long line (51dB) and I am wondering whether moving to ADSL2+ would be an advantage - at present the fastest stable connection speed is about 3776kbps and I would need to bounce it up to 4,000 kbps to get to the next IP profile
You have a problem somewhere. You should be connecting at 4.5Mbps to over 6Mbps, depending on the condition of your line. Not 3776kbps.
On admittedly a very clean line I connected consistently at 6464kbps on ADSL Max with attenuation 52dB. Replaced the Linksys WAG54GS that gave that with a Speedtouch 585v6. That showed an attenuation of 49dB and gave 7104kbps as soon as connected. From then on varied between about 6800 and 7200.
From those exceptionally good figures I expected about 9Mbps on O2 ADSL2+. 'Twas not to be. I got normal ADSL2+ speeds for the attenuation.
Which brings me to the thread in general.
In summary, if you lose more speed from a 3dB rise in attenuation than you gain from ADSL2+ frequencies and technology, you lose speed. On low attenuations you gain a huge amount from the ADSL2+. Simple.
Why?
ADSL2+ normally adds about 3dB to your attenuation, because the higher frequencies it has available attenuate more. With lines that achieve 6Mbps and below on
ADSL because of the attenuation then those higher frequencies often (not always) don't come into play anyway once that 3dB is added!
I don't know about top-end modem/routers, but normal domestic ones aren't clever enough to realise this, and the high attenuation is applied during the speed negotiation with the exchange. So ADSL2+ can even give lower speed than ADSL. The lower the ADSL speed beforehand, the more this happens. Each line is different, and some 6Mbps ones do gain a bit but not a lot.
If you can get your ISP, or tweak your router, to force ADSL2 instead of ADSL2+, this uses the same frequencies as ADSL without the extra ADSL2+ ones. But it uses those freqencies better. So the attenuation stays as it is and the speed usually increases a bit. Not a lot though.
ADSL2 on this length of line is also usually more stable than ADSL2+. The higher frequencies are more sensitive to noise.
I hope that helps everyone. Re yourself, as I said at the start,
Summat's oop!
My broadband basic info/help site - www.robertos.me.uk
My domains,website and mail hosting - Tsohost.
Internet connection - O2 Standard.
Edited by RobertoS (Sat 21-Aug-10 13:02:33)