The post expressed an opinion, yours was directly personal.

A post is not trolling simply because it expresses an opinion with which you disagree or do not like. That also applies to posts criticising TalkTalk as an ISP, which you are prone to jump on with monotonous regularity.

Whether or not that criticism is justified, TalkTalk is big enough (and its customers intelligent enough) to have no need for a White Knight.

In reply to a post by billford:

(and its customers intelligent enough) to have no need for a White Knight.

What about potential customers?

I think it is unfair that potential customers could be put off joining TT after reading some of the posts here especially the ones from X customers with outdated views or from those who have never been a TT customer yet feel it necessary to add their negative views here.

In reply to a post by Jack_Hackett:

What about potential customers?

I think it is unfair that potential customers could be put off joining TT after reading some of the posts here especially the ones from X customers with outdated views or from those who have never been a TT customer yet feel it necessary to add their negative views here.

Exactly.

On the contrary by continuously battling with every poster that remotely slights talktalk in anyway he draws attention to its failings more than if the posts were left to be disregarded by most of the forum readers. He has also helped to give this forum a reputation that makes newcomers feel unwelcome.

In reply to a post by Deputy_Dog:

On the contrary by continuously battling with every poster that remotely slights talktalk in anyway he draws

I do not "battle" with every poster and you know it, I only add my views if the type of poster mentioned in my last post posts their outdated views, this is something that unfortunately happens often..

attention to its failings more than if the posts were left to be disregarded by most of the forum readers. He has also helped to give this forum a reputation that makes newcomers feel unwelcome.

So you think it is fair for the people I mentioned in my last post to post outdated views of TT and the actual customer who know what they post is not true should keep quiet?

In reply to a post by Jack_Hackett:

In reply to a post by Deputy_Dog:

On the contrary by continuously battling with every poster that remotely slights talktalk in anyway he draws

I do not "battle" with every poster and you know it, I only add my views if the type of poster mentioned in my last post posts their outdated views, this is something that unfortunately happens often..

attention to its failings more than if the posts were left to be disregarded by most of the forum readers. He has also helped to give this forum a reputation that makes newcomers feel unwelcome.

So you think it is fair for the people I mentioned in my last post to post outdated views of TT and the actual customer who know what they post is not true should keep quiet?

I was going to ignore Jacks posts but he has accused me of being a troll, which I find very amusing as I have only contributed one previous posting on this thread and I made no anti TT comments. Even if I had made an anti TT comment under his definition it would be ok as I do have a TT account albeit not broadband.

Personally I have no problem with people posting comments in favour of TT. I only object when posters start posting uncalled for remarks. Put it this way if Jack was anti TT and carried on in the same vain I would still want him banned!

I was going to ignore Jacks posts but

You couldn't resist.

In reply to a post by Jack_Hackett:

I was going to ignore Jacks posts but

You couldn't resist.

Um...Pot, kettle, black. That's half your trouble Jack. You could do so much more good by posting less, and being more constructive when you do post.

In reply to a post by Futaura:

In reply to a post by Jack_Hackett:

I was going to ignore Jacks posts but

You couldn't resist.

Um...Pot, kettle, black. That's half your trouble Jack. You could do so much more good by posting less, and being more constructive when you do post.

It was a joke hence the , you are another who cannot resist jumping on the band wagon, i hope you are not too offended if i ignore your advice.


.

Edited by Jack_Hackett (Sat 12-Feb-11 11:25:59)

Can I suggest stopping here and considering how childish you are making yourself look?

At end the day no one opinion about any product is correct, why? Because its an opinion, and when people talk of their experiences nothing wrong in people doing this, so long as its clear it is their experience.

What is needed from people is a degree of common sense, and if that does not appear then people will be given a break to consider getting some.