Technical Discussion
  >> Technical Issues


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.


These posts have been archived and can no longer be replied to or modified.
Pages in this thread: 1 | 2 | 3 | (show all)   Print Thread
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 10:30:36
Print Post

Old Drop Wire And SNR


[link to this post]
 
I
Standard User Zarjaz
(learned) Sat 28-Oct-06 10:42:34
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:

My question is, if this drop wire were (somehow!) replaced by BT with a new twisted pair cable, is this likely to improve my SNR?



I very much doubt it. Your old dropwire 3, as it is known, is as you say not a twisted pair, but on the plus side the conductor size is much greater than the new stuff.

In reply to:

would replacing the final 10-15 metres of cable in a 3.7KM run make no noticeable difference?



You got it.

In reply to:

Does anyone know if these old drop wires can be troublesome to ADSL



No more than any other.

Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 12:59:00
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
Sounds like you've done all the right things - I heard that BT will put your overhead wire underground for free - if you dig the trench and lay the duct for it !

The only other thing I can suggest is that you might gain a little by changing the router to one where you can adjust the target SNR with the DMT utility from dmt.mhilfe.de (I'm not sure whether the Belkin can be used with this). I have a Speedtouch 546 (two in fact, see my sig), and these will reliably sync down to 3dB. Even after the 10-day training, your profile will still follow the modem sync speeds. I have to say that 3.5M isn't bad for a 50'ish attenuation, so you are clutching at straws a little, and if you do buy another router, it may not make any difference at all.

Edited by deleted (Sat 28-Oct-06 13:04:33)


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.

Standard User Zarjaz
(learned) Sat 28-Oct-06 13:24:40
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:

I heard that BT will put your overhead wire underground for free - if you dig the trench and lay the duct for it



Not true.

Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 14:41:11
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:


Sounds like you've done all the right things - I heard that BT will put your overhead wire underground for free - if you dig the trench and lay the duct for it !




This would mean digging up the driveway, a bit of a drastic (and expensive!) thing to do incase it MIGHT mean I got an extra half a meg download speed. I'd stick with what I've got unless replacing the overhead cable might improve things.

In reply to:


The only other thing I can suggest is that you might gain a little by changing the router to one where you can adjust the target SNR with the DMT utility




That looks like a useful utility, but it says it's for Thompson products, so I don't know whether it would work with Belkin? I've already recently replaced the router. Originally (when I was on 2 MB fixed speeds) I had the older Belkin 7630, which occasionally lost sync and could be a pain to get re-connected. I replaced it with the 7633 which is much more stable, but the SNR seems to fluctuate a lot more...

In reply to:


I have to say that 3.5M isn't bad for a 50'ish attenuation, so you are clutching at straws a little, and if you do buy another router, it may not make any difference at all.




I don't think it's worth replacing the router for the time being, especially as I only spent
Standard User yarwell
(legend) Sat 28-Oct-06 14:44:27
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
not clear on the question, a 2272 sync (ATM rate) gets a 2M profile (TCP/IP rate) which speedtests at about 1880 kbits/s of data. 8128 = 7.15M = 6700 kbits/s on same basis.

Phil

666 kbytes/s with Demon

MaxDSL speeds - what do they all mean.
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 14:55:39
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: Zarjaz] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:


I very much doubt it. Your old dropwire 3, as it is known, is as you say not a twisted pair, but on the plus side the conductor size is much greater than the new stuff.




I'd noticed the conductors were much thicker than the new cable, so would offer less resistance, I was just a bit concerned that not been twisted pair, it might be more prone to picking things up like AM radio and interference from the nearby streetlight more?

BT have recently replaced all the telegraph poles on our street recently for some reason, except for ours, which appears to have a split down the middle (!!!) So what I was hoping for is if they do get round to replacing ours in the near future, they'll also replace the dropwire...

If that happens and it does improve my stats enough for a stable 4MB, I'll be very happy! But if it makes no difference and I'm stuck with 3.5MB, then I'll be satisfied with what I've got. It's still 7 times faster than my first 512K broadband connection, and almost 90 times faster than the connection I had on dialup!

Tim
Standard User yarwell
(legend) Sat 28-Oct-06 15:04:48
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
there is a DMT version for the Belkin

# DMT v8.04
Speedport 500V/W500V, Siemens SLI-5300-I/SL2-141-I, Speedtouch 716g, Belkin 7633,
T-Sinus 1054 DSL, BT Voyager 2091/2100/2110, Linksys WAG54GS, USRobotics 9107/9108,
Netgear DG834GT/DG834PNB, Hitachi AH4222, (BCM6348 adslctl)

Phil

666 kbytes/s with Demon

MaxDSL speeds - what do they all mean.
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 15:13:34
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: yarwell] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:


not clear on the question, a 2272 sync (ATM rate) gets a 2M profile (TCP/IP rate) which speedtests at about 1880 kbits/s of data. 8128 = 7.15M = 6700 kbits/s on same basis.




For fixed rate speeds such as 2MB, they, as you say, give you a sync rate of 2272 (2.2MB) which gives you a 2MB profile/throughput after ATM overheads. So the actual throughput speed you get is the same 2MB as what the product is advertised at.

For 8MB max on a good line, you get an 8128 sync (8.1MB) but after taking into account the overheads, you can only get a maximum throughput of 7.15MB, not the advertised 8MB.

My question is, according to BT's "guestimator" my line should support a max speed of "4MB or greater". Does this refer to a 4MB sync speed ie 4000, which would give me a 3.5MB profile, or a 4MB profile/throughput speed, for which I'd need a sync of 4544?

I'm guessing it means a 4MB sync speed and 3.5MB profile/throughput, because if I put in a number closer to the exchange into the checker it says a max speed of 5.5 - 8MB should be possible, and I know that the 8MB has to refer to sync speed and not throughput!

I know the BT checker is only an estimate, and either way it makes no difference to my end result, I was just wondering because BT don't make it clear exactly what the 4MB it thinks my line can handle means? 4000kbps sync, or 4544kbps sync?

Tim


Standard User yarwell
(legend) Sat 28-Oct-06 15:24:55
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
the checker talks about ATM rate = sync rate.

The "8M" marketing claims started with UKonline and Bulldog followed.

Phil

666 kbytes/s with Demon

MaxDSL speeds - what do they all mean.
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 16:07:34
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: yarwell] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:


the checker talks about ATM rate = sync rate.




I thought so, thanks. At lease I know now that even if I'm getting a 4000 sync and 3.5MB profile, it's what BT think my line is capable of, so in my case, the checker is accurate.

One thing that made me wonder, although I always thought it was a marketing claim, was a call I got from Homecall (Pipex) a few months ago saying my 2MB line speed would be "doubled" to 4MB if I upgraded.

In reply to:


The "8M" marketing claims started with UKonline and Bulldog followed.




I remember this. Most providers are now offering up to 8MB products, and some up to 16MB or even 24MB. When I originally upgraded from dialup to half a meg broadband, I noticed a phenominal difference in both speed and reliability with everything from web browsing to downloading large files. But with subsequent upgrades to 2MB and then 3.5/4MB, I've seen no noticeable difference with things like web browsing and e-mail. Where the difference is noticeable is when downloading large files from a fast server. It makes me wonder whether people on 16MB plus connections actually see any benefit over a connection of a few MB?

Tim

Edited by deleted (Sat 28-Oct-06 16:08:41)

Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 16:07:58
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:

I'd noticed the conductors were much thicker than the new cable, so would offer less resistance, I was just a bit concerned that not been twisted pair, it might be more prone to picking things up like AM radio and interference from the nearby streetlight more?



I would say that you're right. The thickness of the conductors will make little if any difference because we're talking about quite low currents here, so voltage drop is not a big issue. But twisting the conductors will make a big difference in the possibility of interference pickup.

Eric
Standard User pitnicker
(knowledge is power) Sat 28-Oct-06 18:41:47
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:

I fitted a faceplate filter from Clarity, re-located the router to within 2 metres of the master socket and connected it with a Belkin shielded twisted pair RJ11 lead.




Rather than attacking the drop wire, the belkin cable is probably a better subject for your attention. I had one and it added about 1.5dB of noise compared to the flat rj11 lead which came with the router. The shielding is pointless if it is not earthed or something done to it. Probably the impedance of the cable is a bad match, but it _looks_ like what you would expect for a decent cable, so sales are probably decent. I suggest try experimenting with a short length of plain rj11.

=======================================
Everything below the line above is my sig
[Notice: Private mail is turned on, but anything received by these means can and will be published]
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 21:43:03
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:


The thickness of the conductors will make little if any difference because we're talking about quite low currents here, so voltage drop is not a big issue. But twisting the conductors will make a big difference in the possibility of interference pickup.




That's my line of thinking. The dropwire is only 10-15 metres long, so it's not volt drop that's an issue, but as it runs across probably the most vulnerable to interference part of the network, straight up the outside wall of the house, then suspended up and across the driveway to the pole with a street light in fairly close proximity, it has the potential of acting as a huge aerial! As I understand it, twisting the pairs drastically reduces interference pickup.

Am I right in thinking that replacing this wire with a twisted pair won't make matters worse, might one one hand not make any difference (so nothing would be lost!) but on the other hand might reduce noise pick up on the line? Whether or not it would make a difference would depend on whether or not the old dropwire is picking up any interference or not to start with, something that couldn't be ascertained unless it were replaced and results compared...

My hoping is that BT will replace the telegraph pole at the top of our drive like they've replaced all the others on the street and several others across the village over the last month or so, and replace the dropwire, for free, when they do this (is there anywhere on the net to find out about planned engineering work?). If this doesn't happen, what's the best way to get it replaced? Ring them up and ask them to do it (would they do this? would they charge?) or maybe it could have an "accident" after a storm (I really wouldn't want to consider anything like that, unless it really was a last resort!). Or maybe even reporting that the pole has a split down the middle (which it has!) would get them to replace it and the cabling?

Tim
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 21:53:24
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: pitnicker] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:


Rather than attacking the drop wire, the belkin cable is probably a better subject for your attention. I had one and it added about 1.5dB of noise compared to the flat rj11 lead which came with the router.




The first thing I did when I brought this cable was to test it against the old one, and mine didn't degrade my stats. It could be that maybe you either had a faulty cable, or something in your system didn't agree with it, maybe as you say causing a mismatch. The exact properties of every line will be different, perhaps you just got unlucky?

In reply to:


The shielding is pointless if it is not earthed or something done to it.




I read at the time I brought it that the sheielding wasn't connected to anything, so probably wouldn't make much, if any difference. The main reason I made the invesment was because it's a twisted pair cable, and I wanted to make sure that absolutely every part of my internal wiring was as good as I could get it before applying for Max.

Tim

Standard User pitnicker
(knowledge is power) Sat 28-Oct-06 22:04:54
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:

The first thing I did when I brought this cable was to test it against the old one, and mine didn't degrade my stats.




Did it improve them??? I think you have damned the cable with faint praise.

In reply to:

It could be that maybe you either had a faulty cable,




I doubt it for a 1.5dB increase in noise, and power levels the same. It was just a rubbish cable. You can't even say it was twisted wrongly, as a flat cable worked better.

In reply to:

or something in your system didn't agree with it, maybe as you say causing a mismatch




I have no reason whatsover to think that my system is responsible for the failure of a belkin cable. Whatever coild have been wrong with my system, the belkin cable should have made it better, certinly not worse, inless the cable was rubbish

In reply to:

The exact properties of every line will be different, perhaps you just got unlucky?




Well unless you have registered an improvement, I don't think you have got lucky

=======================================
Everything below the line above is my sig
[Notice: Private mail is turned on, but anything received by these means can and will be published]
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sat 28-Oct-06 22:38:42
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
They will probably be replacing the poles due to either damage (e.g. hedgecutting/rotten) or to meet minimum height requirements for drop wires across carriageways.

"what's the best way to get it replaced? Ring them up and ask them to do it (would they do this? would they charge?) or maybe it could have an "accident" after a storm (I really wouldn't want to consider anything like that, unless it really was a last resort!). Or maybe even reporting that the pole has a split down the middle (which it has!)"

Of those options the latter is probably the only option I could possibly suggest.
Of course you could just leave it as it is.
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sun 29-Oct-06 06:51:34
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to:

Am I right in thinking that replacing this wire with a twisted pair won't make matters worse, might one one hand not make any difference (so nothing would be lost!) but on the other hand might reduce noise pick up on the line? Whether or not it would make a difference would depend on whether or not the old dropwire is picking up any interference or not to start with, something that couldn't be ascertained unless it were replaced and results compared...



I would say that's spot on.

Eric
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sun 29-Oct-06 08:21:34
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
Is the pole which BT didn't replace carrying anything other than phone cables ? In rural areas some poles carry electric cables too, and if that's the case, BT have to liase with the electricity company.

Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sun 29-Oct-06 12:15:03
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
No, just telephone services. This isn't a rural area, but on the edge of Chesterfield, a large town. Electricity supplies are all underground feeds.

The next pole down from us was replaced 2 weeks ago which would have been about the same age as ours, around 40 years. The pole up from ours, which was probably older, has also been recently replaced, as have a number of others around here. I've seen BT replacing at least 2 others as I've been driving past in the last few weeks, and looking around (I'd not really taken any notice until now) most of the poles that I pass on the way into town look brand new...

BT installed an additional metal pole on the one down from us to serve the houses on the opposite side of the wooden pole they replaced (to stop the cables drooping across the road maybe?) and the one up from us does look a lot taller, so minimum hight requirements could have something to do with it.

The cables from our pole do seems to droop a lot by comparisson to the new ones, but I don't know whether or not they're below minimum requirements, and the actual pole does seem to be splitting in several places, but again I don't know whether or not this is so bad as to be a hazzard for someone climbing it, I know I wouldn't like to try it!

I think it might be a case of wait and see. If it's not been touched within say the next 6 months, I might try saying something.

Tim
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Sun 29-Oct-06 12:22:54
Print Post

Re: Old Drop Wire And SNR


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
The splits are known as 'shakes' and are nothing to worry about.

The labels on the pole will say when it was last tested and if it is defective.
Pages in this thread: 1 | 2 | 3 | (show all)   Print Thread

Jump to