Technical Discussion
  >> Technical Issues


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.


These posts have been archived and can no longer be replied to or modified.
  Print Thread
Standard User JoeKidd
(committed) Mon 20-Apr-09 14:25:26
Print Post

BT line problem or Router problem ?


[link to this post]
 
I am on the O2 20 Mb/s package and have recently been having "loss of sync" problems on my line. Have seen random disconnections over the last year or so but these were not a big problem until a few weeks ago when the frequency of the disconnections have increased from say one or two times a day to several in an hour. I was pretty sure that it was a BT line noise problem and called them twice in the last 6 months when I heard random crackling on the line and also in the quiet line test (17070) - however BT did a quick "test" of the line from their end and said they found nothing wrong and said they would make the usual charge of ~ £200 if the cause was found to be inside my house.

I did several tests on the extensions and in the test socket inside the BT master socket (fitted with the XTE-2005 filtered faceplate). Tested two routers (LinkSys WAG200G and the O2 box which is a speedtouch 585 v7) and four different ADSL filters.

Bottom line is that there is no crackling noise on the phone when the phones are connected to the TEST SOCKET or tel. socket ex faceplate - when the routers are NOT connected (Note, however, the test for crackling has not been done over a long period (i.e. longer than a couple of minutes each time with the phone off the hook).

When the router is connected, via filter even on the test socket, crackling is heard on the phone (applies to both routers tested)
During steady operation (i.e. good periods) the variation of noise margin on the Linksys router is more severe (6 dB down to 2 or 3 dB) compared to O2 ox (6 dB +/- 0.5 dB). Noise margin variation was monitored on RouterStats Lite and sudden drops to zero dB are seen with both routers - also at both 6 dB and 15 dB default Noise Margins (default noise margin changed to 15dB and back to 6 dB by O2 Technical support). When the sudden margin drops happen, I've observed during the last weekend that nothing was happening inside the house (i.e. no electrical equipment switched on/off, no phones in use etc.)

The telephone line comes from a box on a pole on the street to anoither box on a pole on my property (~ 100 feet away) from where three lines are distributed - one to my property and two to other adjacent properties. There is another junction box on my house wall (outside) before it enters the house and connects to the BT master socket (I opened this box and cleaned out some spider cobwebs but the joints were the standard BT waterproof gel contacts) . Between the pole on the street and my BT master socket there are several trees where the wire touches or is slightly stretched by banches/twigs when it is windy.
I speculated that the junction boxes on the BT poles on street and on my property may have had random water ingress into the joints causing random interference to the line. I also checked with my neighbour to see if they had crackling on the phone and we both thought we did hear faint & random cracking - although not 100% sure and not as bad as on my line when the disconnections happen.

The question is: is this almost certainly a BT line problem or are there any more tests I should do before calling them out to the house to check the line.

Thanks
Standard User Zarjaz
(knowledge is power) Wed 22-Apr-09 18:55:26
Print Post

Re: BT line problem or Router problem ?


[re: JoeKidd] [link to this post]
 
The question is: is this almost certainly a BT line problem or are there any more tests I should do before calling them out to the house to check the line.

Why risk it ? It's the broadband issue you are reporting. Get your ISP to report the issue.

Standard User JoeKidd
(committed) Wed 22-Apr-09 19:38:39
Print Post

Re: BT line problem or Router problem ?


[re: Zarjaz] [link to this post]
 
I called O2 and they said it is a BT problem and I should report it as a voice fault.

Since then the line has deteriorated a lot (disconnections every few minutes) and there is clearly audible crackling on the phone when it is connected to the test socket even without a router connected. I called BT today and they heard the crackling while I was talking to them - they are sending a man tomorrow.
I also saw through a binoculars, pigeon droppings on the BT junction box on the pole - some conifer trees near this pole were cut a few months back to below the level of the wire and this allowed pigeons to sit on top of the pole ! However, as the junction box looks like a waterproof one, I doubt if this is the cause. As the problem appears at random intervals, I'm hoping that the cause is a corroded joint or water ingress somewhere. Will know tomorrow !


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.

Standard User JoeKidd
(committed) Sat 25-Apr-09 11:29:07
Print Post

Re: BT line problem or Router problem ?


[re: JoeKidd] [link to this post]
 
Two Openreach engineers came two days ago and inspected/replaced the joints on three junctions boxes (outside of house, and two telephones poles) and also checked the main telephone box on the street. At the end of their visit although the telephone was clear, later I could still hear some random crackling/hissing on the test socket when the router is connected.
Called O2 and they reset the default margin to 15 dB and they started their 24 hr line quality testing. Over the next 6 hours there were several drops in noise margin to 0 and disconnections. However, for about 10 hours after that the line was fine with no disconnections. When I called O2 yesterday evening, the line appeared to be fine and there was no crackling at all - however, they said that before they contact BT to resolve this permamently, the next step would be to test a new router which they're sending. Meanwhile, I noticed there was only one disconnection after that and noise margin has been very steady overnight (15 +/- 0.5 dB).
I am still not sure what the cause of the problem is. The frequency of occurrence of the noise interference is much reduced now but I'm not convinced that the problem has been solved permanently.

Questions:
Can routers lead to severe random drops of noise margin and/or result in crackling/hissing on the voice line ?
Could the random interference come from the O2 LLU kit at the exchange ?
Standard User dandnsmith
(experienced) Sat 25-Apr-09 12:03:23
Print Post

Re: BT line problem or Router problem ?


[re: JoeKidd] [link to this post]
 
If your router is connected and active, you will get noises if you don't put a filter between the phone and the line.
You talk about connecting a router via a filter - but it's the phone needs the filter.

Derek
Standard User JoeKidd
(committed) Sat 25-Apr-09 12:56:41
Print Post

Re: BT line problem or Router problem ?


[re: dandnsmith] [link to this post]
 
To clarify, I am connected to the test socket inside the BT master socket.
An ADSL filter is connected to the test socket and one outlet of the filter is connected to the phone and the other outlet is connected to the router.

The problem is that noise margin drops suddenly to zero and the sync is lost. At this point if I pick up the phone, I can hear crackling/hissing noises. When the interference goes away a minute or so later, the line is connected as normal and there is no crackling/hissing. This drop in noise margin was happening very frequently until yesterday (hundreds of disconnections/day) and during the last 24 hours I've had only two disconnections.
  Print Thread

Jump to