As your posts are huge and you seem reluctant to clarify the number change scenario then I can only assume that this is the crux of the matter.
Just noticed another post where you state that BT assured you that adsl (with another provider) would not be affected by a number change. How could BT guarantee what another company's response would be?
The number change scenario is simple and I am not reluctant to clarify it. I was with PlusNet since Nov. 2003. I changed my phone number 3 years ago around 2010. BT assured me the number change did not matter, I did not have reason to question what the boffins were telling me. Service with PlusNet continued without a glitch all these past 3 years suposedly feeding the signal to the user whose number had been changed at the Exchange with a routine redirection instruction. I guess this was transparent to both PlusNet and myself if BT had configured that any signals to the old number should then be redirected to the new number. At the time of the number change BT knew I got my ADSL service from PlusNet who by then was a BT company. BT must have known what they were doing.
I believe if there were to be any ADSL issues with the number change and the BT boffins were wrong at the time, problems would have cropped up rather immediately instead of waiting 3 years and would have been sorted out quite quickly. Also, Plusnet only deleted my account and username, they did nothing with my phone number, as it is evident from their emails.
The error scenario in PlusNet could be that someone assumed I needed a MAC code, when this was clearly not the case as they had the evidence from my new LLU ISP, and as they could see no MAC code from me they cancelled the service, but even this does not explain why PlusNet AGREED a date of 13th May and pulled the plug on me 11 days earlier. The instruction to delete my account must have come to the new number.