User comments on ISPs
  >> BT Broadband


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.


Pages in this thread: 1 | 2 | 3 | [4] | 5 | 6 | (show all)   Print Thread
Standard User ian72
(eat-sleep-adslguide) Mon 17-May-21 10:43:42
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: RobertoS] [link to this post]
 
I had the same letter/email from BT.

There is a news article on the TBB home page about this as well.

The signal will no longer be turned into analogue at the exchange but instead will be delivered to the smarthub 2 as digital which will then convert it to analogue for the bt phone port on the back. When then plugging in a handset that hanset will act exactly the same as when it was plugged in to the old copper phone line - to the handset it still is plugged in to a standard analogue phone line.

However, BT also sell wifi handsets that connect to the router over wifi and therefore don't need to plug in to any phone port. They are currently doing an offer where they will give them to people if they sign up - I think the details of how to do so were in the email. They also do a wireless box that delivers an analogue port if you want to use a phone with a standard BT plug but not put it where the router is.
Standard User trolleybus
(experienced) Mon 17-May-21 11:11:17
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: RobertoS] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by RobertoS:
In reply to a post by Realalemadrid:
Posting in the early hours has led to huge confusion. You need to reconsider in the cold light of day.

MHC's The SmartHub BT socket can only provide an analog phone signal, there can be no conversion back to digital.

The N300 could of course handle both VOIP services but BT in their wisdom will not give out the VOIP registration details for their Digital Voice so it has to come from the SmartHub analog output.
smile
I wasn't aware that BT were being sticky wrt the DV registration details, so thanks for that. Typical of them.

But.

Plug in a DECT base station such as the N300 and that converts it back to digital. That was the final step I described. Madness that BT don't allow it straight through like the Voipfone signal. Lack of thinking it through at the design stage and only catering for people on copper, or an odd management decision.


Have a look at page 9 of the URL https://www.voipon.co.uk/documents/N300-User-Manual.pdf

The OP has a Gigaset N300 IP base station. Currently his analogue service s provided from the copper wire connected master socket but will at some time by switched over to the DV socket of the BT router. At that time he will need to physically move over the telephone cable from the master socket to the DV socket of the router. His basic question was really "would it work?" the answer being yes.

There is no need to know the credentials of the DV service, but would be nice to know should you wish to use something other than the BT supplied router to which a VoIP enabled phone or base station would plug until any port of the router.

The OP has the best of both worlds from a single, or multiple, phone(s); the BT DV service and a service, or services, from hosted VoIP providers like Sipgate or Voipfone.
Standard User RobertoS
(elder) Mon 17-May-21 13:22:29
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: trolleybus] [link to this post]
 
I don't think you have added to my knowledge there, except for the information that Voipfone apparently tell us more about the N300 than the Gigaset manual seems to. But as far as I'm concerned the topic served its purpose when the OP got the answer.

I merely posted again in it as a polite response to a previous reply to me smile.

My broadband basic info/help site - www.robertos.me.uk. Domains, sites and mail hosting - Tsohost & Ionos.
Connections: OnePlus 8 Pro max 165Mbps down, 24Mbps up on Three, and B311 4G, tbb tests normally 35-45Mpbs down, 65Mbps off-peak, 9-24 up.
========================
The EU’s multiple failures are due to a deeper malaise .... What malaise? The EU’s formidable immunity to the smallest amount of democracy. New Statesman Feb 2021.


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.

Standard User Realalemadrid
(committed) Mon 17-May-21 22:19:26
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: RobertoS] [link to this post]
 
Thanks for your reply, I still think you have not quite got it. Have you any hands on experience of a Gigaset VoIP phone base station? I have. In fixed line mode the PSTN connection is used in a landline BT socket or alternatively when DV is present in the Smarthub PSTN output then the phone is a effectively a landline phone no VoIP involved no conversion back to digital.

I expect BT have locked the VoIP registration down because a large proportion of users would get it wrong or change things that cause problems giving support staff a nightmare.

I don't quite follow why you think it is only catering for users on copper, DV can be on any service, Fibre or xDSL.
Standard User RobertoS
(elder) Tue 18-May-21 01:24:44
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: Realalemadrid] [link to this post]
 
The N300 is a DECT base station! (With an additional analogue input port).
Digital enhanced cordless telecommunications (Digital European cordless telecommunications), usually known by the acronym DECT, is a standard primarily used for creating cordless telephone systems.
It's a digital phone system, just like your mobile is a digital phone.

DECT handsets are digital. The transmission between base station and handset is digital, measured in kbps. With, to be pedantic, a final conversion in the handset back again to analogue so your ear can hear it.

Re your "I don't quite follow why you think it is only catering for users on copper, DV can be on any service, Fibre or xDSL", I don't think I have ever said that*. I am fully aware, and always have been, that it is available on xDSL and FTTC. What I did wrongly say, in my ignorance of BT's restriction, was that the OP's copper would become redundant once their FTTP was in place.

As it should!

Your suggestion about the reasons for BT locking down the credentials is valid in a way, but as far as I know doesn't worry any other VOIP providers. Once PSTN is dead, non-broadband landline users are surely going to need a modem, i.e. a smaller cheaper version of the Hub? By definition Openreach/BT can't send an analogue "digital voice" down the copper unless it goes to a digital receiver. The copper becomes ADSLx (or ISDN) from the original copper source exchange. Which sounds crazy.

The current BT base stations take the analogue signal and convert it to digital for communication with the handsets. The Gigaset one also does that, as well as being able to take the DV one direct over ethernet. Just BT won't allow the latter.

As a BT Hub still requires a password to use its WiFi, will the modem need one too? If so, what's the difference between that and giving them the credentials for the DV? Or even, if they make the modem not need any credentials, why would DV on FTTx need them?

We don't need credentials for PSTN.

Your suggestion doesn't make sense to me, for those reasons.

It'll be interesting to see what the other CPs do. Including those that do phone-only rather than with a broadband service.

*Edit: Ah. I think I have spotted where I accidentally misled you with "Lack of thinking it through at the design stage and only catering for people on copper, or an odd management decision". It was late at night, though not quite as late as this post wink.

"People on copper" there means people who still use a landline phone with their broadband and have not switched to third-party VOIP already. BT could have included the analogue phone socket on the Hub purely so such copper users did not have to change their phone kit once their master socket no longer carried a PSTN signal. I hope that clears that up.

My broadband basic info/help site - www.robertos.me.uk. Domains, sites and mail hosting - Tsohost & Ionos.
Connections: OnePlus 8 Pro max 165Mbps down, 24Mbps up on Three, and B311 4G, tbb tests normally 35-45Mpbs down, 65Mbps off-peak, 9-24 up.
========================
The EU’s multiple failures are due to a deeper malaise .... What malaise? The EU’s formidable immunity to the smallest amount of democracy. New Statesman Feb 2021.

Edited by RobertoS (Tue 18-May-21 01:44:24)

Standard User deleted
(deleted) Tue 18-May-21 08:28:23
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: RobertoS] [link to this post]
 
I think one point worth noting is that some audio quality will be lost when using the BT hubs digital voice analogue port to connect to a Gigaset N300 fixed line analogue port as the working frequency range is likely to be between 20hz and 20khz between these two points which isn't as good as it going digital all the way to the handset via a VOIP style of service.
Standard User MHC
(sensei) Tue 18-May-21 10:43:55
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
Don't believe that will be a problem. In the old BT badged 2-wire HG27xx ADSL/VDSLhub there were two ATAs which could be linked to BTs earlier VoIP product and they presented two standard BT sockets. I ran those into DECT base stations or various types and never had any audio issues.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

M H C


taurus excreta cerebrum vincit
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Tue 18-May-21 10:59:05
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: MHC] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by MHC:
Don't believe that will be a problem.
Totally agree, was just pointing out that some quality would be lost because of the analogue interface into the N300 compared to digital all the way to the handset but if the OP was happy with their copper service they will be equally happy with this solution smile
Standard User Realalemadrid
(committed) Tue 18-May-21 21:22:41
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: RobertoS] [link to this post]
 
I am now going to attempt to be more pedantic than yourself, which is a tall ordersmile

I know perfectly well that the D in DECT stands for digital and how the base station and handsets communicate via a digital wireless connection. I hacked a locked down Tesco VOIP Gigaset base station years ago to change the SIP registration to get it to work on a Plusnet Broadband service.

Digital can mean many things, VOIP is a digital protocol, so is DECT wi-fi but completely different so I cannot agree with your statement that the N300 .....

converts it back to digital

Converting back implies returning to a previous state or situation which is not happening, the phone is converting analog signals to DECT wi-fi not to VoIP protocol which to me seemed to be what you were suggesting.

It seems that the reason for DV being locked down is to meet Government Security rules as it will be a replacement for the copper PSTN service.

Have a look at this very long thread where the DV VoIP credential security is discussed and a convoluted method to use a different router but still have DV is described.

Smart Hub DV
Standard User Michael_Chare
(knowledge is power) Tue 18-May-21 23:10:43
Print Post

Re: Has anyone removed their BT landline?


[re: Realalemadrid] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by Realalemadrid:
I expect BT have locked the VoIP registration down because a large proportion of users would get it wrong or change things that cause problems giving support staff a nightmare.
The BT VOIP system is a bit more secure than a normal VOIP service. There was a recent thread about a complex procedure to use other equipment.

Michael Chare
Pages in this thread: 1 | 2 | 3 | [4] | 5 | 6 | (show all)   Print Thread

Jump to