Hi Everyone,
To give you a better idea of what I have in mind I've attached an image to help.
Lounge Plan
As previously mentioned leaving the router next to the modem is not an option and also I'm very reluctant to place it on or in the AV cabinet due to interference so that just leaves the study area.
I've been having ongoing conversations with my ISP explaining this situation which goes as follows:
I asked my ISP to confirm if it was possible to run a CAT5 cable from the modem to either the 5 port switch or the ethernet port (both behind the AV unit), place the router in the study and connect the EWAN to the ethernet socket to which the reply was:
'The router should directly connect to the modem but the cable can be of a longer distance, up to 100 meters usually.
However, we do not recommend connecting through a switch/hub because this may interfere with the PPPoE data that sits between the modem/router and cause unpredictable results. The only exception to this is if the switch supports VLANs and you can create a VLAN for only the modem and router to talk to where they won't see any other device but again, it could be unpredictable in terms of stability.'
I then asked would it help if I placed an ethernet splitter into the socket behind the AV unit and then attached the 5 port switch in 1 side of the splitter and the cable from the modem into the other side? (as you've suggested) and they said:
'I don�t believe this will work i�m afraid.
It has to be a direct connection with a full feed to the modem which a splitter would block.'
I asked if they had any thoughts as to what could be done to which the reply was:
'Bar leaving the router near the modem which isn't possible or having a direct ethernet connection, I don't think there are many other options.'
So now I'm really not sure what to do.
It worries me that there seems to be a difference of opinion, I really dont want to screw up my broadband.