Technical Discussion
  >> Home Networking, Internet Connection Sharing, etc.


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.


These posts have been archived and can no longer be replied to or modified.
Pages in this thread: 1 | [2] | (show all)   Print Thread
Standard User TheBaron
(knowledge is power) Mon 18-Oct-10 22:14:17
Print Post

Re: Gigabit or 100Mb ?


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
Thanks all for input.

Router is in the loft, currently using homeplugs around the house.

I have a Cat5e run to under the stairs which will have an 8 port switch going to 5 locations.

3 of these points are where a TV/PS3/Humax Freesat./PC will live so was going to put 5 port switches behind each of those points. (at the moment only max 2 ethernet devices at each point but will grow soon)

the other two points downstairs would only need single conx.

Price difference on netgear GS/FS108 is only £26 and for the 5 port about £15 difference, so not an issue, but they are not smart like an example I was given,

Won't be doing much file shifting apart from maybe sticking blu ray films on the NAS drive and watching them.

TIA

O2 LLU Premium 20MB + O2 Wireless II or DG834GT

I like pigs. Dogs look up to us. Cats look down on us. Pigs treat us as equals.
Sir Winston Churchill


http://www.speedtest.net/result/932899680.png
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Tue 19-Oct-10 13:15:34
Print Post

Re: Gigabit or 100Mb ?


[re: TheBaron] [link to this post]
 
If it was me I would run more Cat5 to each location and put more switch ports at the core,

Less power consumption.
More reliable.
Better performance.

Again, we could debate for months how much difference the latter point makes in the average home, but using cheap swiches throughout would limit the bandwidth noticeably.

Cheap switches don't have the brains or throughput onboard to operate all ports simultaneously, so will cycle between traffic streams to keep all the plates spinning. Effectively, your Gb bandwidth is split between all the devices that are talking at any one time. You also multiply that effect by cascading the switches - it's why Proper Enterprise Switches can be linked at the backplane level, and not just via a patchlead on the front.

How much you care about that at home though, depends on your budget.

Speaking of which,

3x Netgear GS105 = £135
1x Netgear GS108 = £56

Total = £191,

Unmanaged switches, cascaded, no backplane throughput published, £8.30 per RJ45 port

OR,

1x Netgear GS724T = £175.

Managed switch, 48 Gbps Backplane, 2 GBIC slots for fibre or other interfaces. £7.29 per RJ45 port. (ie, not including GBICs)

So, even allowing for the extra cabling, the costs are very similar.

(prices from comms-express)
Standard User TheBaron
(knowledge is power) Tue 19-Oct-10 18:46:48
Print Post

Re: Gigabit or 100Mb ?


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
Yup, that makes sense, and future proofs...................

I guess any PCs would need Gigabit NICs ?

O2 LLU Premium 20MB + O2 Wireless II or DG834GT

I like pigs. Dogs look up to us. Cats look down on us. Pigs treat us as equals.
Sir Winston Churchill


http://www.speedtest.net/result/932899680.png


Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.

Standard User deleted
(deleted) Tue 19-Oct-10 21:14:01
Print Post

Re: Gigabit or 100Mb ?


[re: TheBaron] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by TheBaron:
I guess any PCs would need Gigabit NICs ?


Start with what you already have, upgrade if you need to. Most recent PC kit has a Gb NIC integrated anyway.
Standard User deleted
(deleted) Wed 20-Oct-10 13:10:40
Print Post

Re: Gigabit or 100Mb ?


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by shtu:
3x Netgear GS105 = £135
1x Netgear GS108 = £56

Total = £191,

Unmanaged switches, cascaded, no backplane throughput published, £8.30 per RJ45 port

OR,

1x Netgear GS724T = £175.

Managed switch, 48 Gbps Backplane, 2 GBIC slots for fibre or other interfaces. £7.29 per RJ45 port. (ie, not including GBICs)


Thinking about those numbers earlier, I realised the gap is actually bigger, as you are using so many switch ports for uplinks in your multi-switch scenario.

23 ports total, minus 6 for uplinks (3 uplinks, one port each end) = 17 usable ports at £11.26 per port.

In my opinion, no contest.
Standard User TheBaron
(knowledge is power) Tue 26-Oct-10 23:59:26
Print Post

Re: Gigabit or 100Mb ?


[re: deleted] [link to this post]
 
In reply to a post by shtu:
In reply to a post by shtu:
3x Netgear GS105 = £135
1x Netgear GS108 = £56

Total = £191,

Unmanaged switches, cascaded, no backplane throughput published, £8.30 per RJ45 port

OR,

1x Netgear GS724T = £175.

Managed switch, 48 Gbps Backplane, 2 GBIC slots for fibre or other interfaces. £7.29 per RJ45 port. (ie, not including GBICs)


Thinking about those numbers earlier, I realised the gap is actually bigger, as you are using so many switch ports for uplinks in your multi-switch scenario.

23 ports total, minus 6 for uplinks (3 uplinks, one port each end) = 17 usable ports at £11.26 per port.

In my opinion, no contest.


Yep, all the cables arrived today, will get the Netgear GS724T, once I can't do by mixture of powerline/borrowed switches...... smile

O2 LLU Premium 20MB + O2 Wireless II or DG834GT

I like pigs. Dogs look up to us. Cats look down on us. Pigs treat us as equals.
Sir Winston Churchill


http://www.speedtest.net/result/932899680.png
Pages in this thread: 1 | [2] | (show all)   Print Thread

Jump to