|
|
|
Been having problems with erratic speeds during the day, not just the bust times, for some months and after finally loosing it with their very poor technical department they asked me to test my speeds using 'The Broadband Speed tester'
Using the thinkbroadband tester my results were 1251 download and 379 upload. Using speedtest.net I had very similar results, 1671 and 398 but once signed in and that's not easy, the above tester gave me the following results
DSL communication 7616 Lbps download, 448 Kbps upload, which I assume is what its supposed to be.
an IP profile of 6500
and an achieved of 4014 Kbps.
As you can only test once every 3 hours I've got to wait so I wondered if anyone else had used this test and could vouch for its veracity.
I have doubts
|
|
|
Might be me, but I'm a bit confused by your post!?
Even though you don't mention it by name I'm guessing you've tried the official BT speedtest: http://speedtester.bt.com ?
Yes you're right, this can be troublesome to use!
Can you post the complete results from this test or if I've guessed wrong perhaps supply some more details?
|
|
|
Sorry
Yes tried the thinkbroadband test and posted the results, then tried http://www.speedtest.net/ posted results and then finally used the Bt tester site as you suggested and got much quicker figures I think, as posted last
DSL Connection 7616Kbps download, 448 Kbps upload
IP Profile 6500
Achieved 4014 Kbps
The latter being 3x the other results, still below my expected but better than the results from the others sites.
|
|
Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.
|
|
|
Hi,
The BT test is the important one.
It looks like you have a good line there. Any reduction in speed from your IP Profile will be either down to your provider throttling the connection or congestion at your exchange.
|
|
|
|
Thanks, that's what I'm trying to determine.
At the moment the TBB test is showing 6202 kbps but at times its so low its under a 100 kbps, and although over the last 3 months I've replaced all sorts of items on f2s instruction, at certain times, especially when I've downloaded large files my speed drops.
Is there a way to determine whether its the provider throttling or congestion, which I doubt as my exchange is supposedly under capacity being in a very rural location
|
|
|
|
The BT speedtester would also be affected by any contention at your local exchange, but would not be affected by your ISP having limited capacity on their BT Central, nor any traffic shaping policies they may have in place.
A very simple diagram is:
Router - DSLAM - Core Network - Speedtester
For 'external' speedtesters such as TBB, it would be more like:
Router - DSLAM - Core Network - BT Central - ISP - Internet - TBB Host link - Speedtester
|
|
|
As long as the official BT test shows you still have a healthy IP Profile then that shows your kit is fine and F2S shouldn't be asking you to change anything.
If you haven't already I would look in the F2S forum - I've just had a very quick look and seen posts about throttling/capacity etc.
Perhaps someone there will also be able to give you a Status page address (if F2S have one) that shows the current F2S broadband usage. I'm with Freeola/Entanet and they have a page that shows how busy things are.
|
|
|
f2s after being shown speeds that varied from 200 to 6500 kbps have told me
ADSL is a contended service, it is sold in this way and has never been sold as anything other than this. A contended service means that you share your bandwidth with other users on your exchange. A fully contended exchange will see you achieving speeds from 400kbps, up to 7150kbps.
So why after 5 weeks of tests and arguments has that little gem appeared ?
Can you find out about the contention on my exchange. Being rural and not an area where I'd expect much usage of the Internet I'm interested to know
|
|
|
Tell them that your money is a contended resource and they have just lost out because you want your MAC. It is true that ADSL is a contended service but there are plenty of ISPs that manage to contend it less than your speed variation suggests is the case here.
If this is IPstream which is likely if you are on a rural exchange then the major point of contention is not the exchange backhaul it is the number of users that cheapskate ISPs try to shove on a BTw central because of the truly staggering amount of money BTw charge for them.
If you can't fix it with a hammer you've got an electrical problem.
|
|
|
Thanks for that.
Having had a nightmare since around 19.00 with line drops the norm and speeds very slow, I did the speedtester again when the line was up for a while and the configured line speed has dropped dramatically to 2500 from 7600kbps
Test1 comprises of Best Effort Test: -provides background information.
Your DSL connection rate: 2720 kbps(DOWN-STREAM), 256 kbps(UP-STREAM)
IP profile for your line is - 3500 kbps
Actual IP throughput achieved during the test was - 2244 kbps
Is that due to contention ratio's or f2s.
|