|
|
|
Hi,
For some time now I have had a problem with my ST585 router.
The problem is that the ADSL connection dies after some time (a few hours). The web page of the router indicates that the DSL is up but the Internet (TCP/IP) is down stating:
Link Status: Disconnected
Last Error Message: Disconnected because idle timeout reached
Using the Internet test facility the results are:
Test Succeeded DSL
Test Failed ATM No ATM activity detected on your DSL line.
Test Failed PPP Disconnected because idle timeout reached
The ADSL router will not reconnect in this condition, only a reboot of the router will work.
I am given to understand that this is an issue with the 6.1.4.3 firmware on the router when on long lines and have contacted Speedtouch about it over 2 months ago. The suggestion was that they were going to release updated firmware but this has not yet happened (as far as I can see).
Has anyone any ideas on how to fix this, perhaps with older firmware otherwise I am going to have to consign this router to the bin ?
Cheers
Terry
|
|
|
|
I'll tell you my experience, I had exactly the same problem, I eventually downgraded the firmware and it was fine. Then a couple of months ago or so I decided to retry the 6143 firmware and it hasn't happened since. The only difference is before I reupgraded to 6143 I did 2 x successive factory resets on the router, it's been fine since.
|
|
|
|
I would certainly be interested in a solution to this as I have had the same problem with my 585. In early January Speedtouch support said that they were aware of the problem and would let me know when there was a solution. To date, I have heard no more from them and think that it is long past the time where they should sort this problem out as several other poeple have reported the same fault on this site.
Meanwhile, my BT Voyager continues to connect without any problem.
I have tried different firmware versions without success. In my case, the router seem to work OK for 2 to 3 days then refuses to connect, even if I reboot. I switch to my Voyager for a few days and then when I go back to the Speedtouch it works again for 2-3 days. Annoying when I need the connectivity for 2 wired PCs and one wireless laptop which the Voyager does not do.
The Speedtouch is often recommended on this site but I for one would not recommend it at all and am hoping to take it back to where I bought it for a refund as I feel I have waited long enough.
|
|
Register (or login) on our website and you will not see this ad.
|
|
|
|
I have just received firmware version 6.2.15.5 from Speedtouch Technical support for UK usage in an attempt to fix the "idle timeout reached" bug. Testing this at the moment. Initial results look good, but DMT no longer works and you cannot set the target SNR using the "adsl config modemoption parameter" ...
|
|
|
Any chance you could put this firmware up somewhere? I don't believe anyone's seen a UK-specific 6.2 firmware anywhere yet.
-
UKFSN Home MAX 30
Powered by entanet
|
|
|
|
Thanks for coming back on this.
I have not received anything from customer support and cannot find their support page at the moment but if anyone knows a location for this new firmware it would be welcome.
|
|
|
|
The Email, with the firmware, that I received from ST explicitly forbids discolsure without the consent of the email author. So I will ask ST if this is Ok to release ...
|
|
|
Fair enough. They'll say no so don't bother emailing them.
-
UKFSN Home MAX 30
Powered by entanet
|
|
|
|
Ok - found the link to the new 6.2.15.5 firmware in the "Speedtouch 6.2.G firmware" topic in this forum. Installed it yesterday and so far OK but usually the problems do not start until after 2-3 days so will wait and see.
|
|
|
|
After 5 days the 6.2.15.5 firmware seems to be working well with no idle timeout errors and longer than normal continuous uptime. Anyone else had any improvements from this ?
|
|
|
|
Spoke too soon. Soon after my last post the Internet light went out (DSL light still on) and it refused to connect even after a reboot. Now back on my BT Voyager which is working OK.
Time the 585 went back to the shop I think.
Any ideas for a replacement suitable for long lines ?
|
|
|
I've had a ST585v6 for a number of months and never seen this problem
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
"Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power."
Abraham Lincoln
16th president of US (1809 - 1865)
|
|
|
Are you 100% certain it's not an ISP initiated disconnect?. IIRC Plusnet had an idle time out on certain products, to free up sessions.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
"Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power."
Abraham Lincoln
16th president of US (1809 - 1865)
|
|
|
|
I would be surprised if my ISP, IDNET initiated a disconnect but whatever causes the disconnect, the problem is that it is often impossible to get it to reconnect even with a reboot. But if I plug in my BT Voyager 205 it works straight away. My line is marginal but the Voyager seems to cope OK and I purchased the 585 on the basis that it was supposed to work well with long lines.
|
|
|
|
I would have to agree with the factory reset thing.
I am stuck on 6.1.4.3 so I can tweak the snr as I'm not prepared to lose this feature with the later firmwares.
Anyway, I had this problem many many months ago until I read try doing a full factory reset back to scratch, then dont fiddle with anything except snr if required.
Mine stays up for weeks at a time and only dies when the snr goes very low for whatever reason (passing aliens or summit!!)
|
|
|
>>>>>>passing aliens or summit!!
hehehe
Tim
ZeN & freenetname
ST546v5 on 8 Meg Active
Check my bad boy speeds out on ZeN
Sign up for Latency Monitoring
|
|
|
|
Its true, it will be fine for weeks then all of a sudden it will fall through the floor, only for 10 maybe 20mins, its probably the women next door and her 'special toys', or it could be the misses and hers !!
|
|
|
I have just had that happen to me for the first time.
It took me about 10 minutes to get online again but miraculously my PPP session hasn't dropped as it still shows the uptime that I had before i.e. the uptime wasn't reset
I wonder if there's a router setting somewhere to stop this happening?
I'm running on the 6 .1 .4 .3 firmware.
|
|
|
|
IDnet's connections have been dropping as i can vouch, also see their forum.
So maybe that new firmware was doing it's job after all.
|
|
|
so far this hasnt happened to me once.
does your line have any traffic going over it when idle?
I have irc/msn/ssh connected at all times which could be why I dont get this problem.
Andrews & Arnold
atten 48.5 - line dist 1.65 straight - 2.96 actual
|
|
|
In reply to:
does your line have any traffic going over it when idle?
I have irc/msn/ssh connected at all times which could be why I dont get this problem.
No I don't have MSN/WLM connected all the time and so what I think you are saying is that the lack of traffic on my connection (when the PC is off) may contribute to the problem?
I'm not really that bothered about it as it has only happened the once but it's annoying when it does happen!
|
|
|
|
The 6.2.15.5 firmware appears to have been working well for some time now.
My router has stayed up although there has been numerous reconnects.
Now I have to try and get my ISP/BT to look into my line problems that are causing the ittermittant low SNR's ....
|
|
|
|
Well it's just happened again after 3 days of working.
Dsl light on, Internet off and "Disconnected due to idle time out reached". Try to connect manually - no success, Reset to factory settings - no success, Re-type password - no success, plug in BT Voyager - connected in seconds.
It's not the fact that it disconnects that is the problem, I accept that my line is so poor that this is going to happen, the problem is that the Speedtouch will not reconnect when the Voyager will.
In January Speedtouch support said
"This is a known issue , that is being worked on. I will keep you informed of any developments." When I asked for progress on March 8th I just got an acknowledgement of my email.
Meanwhile I have bought a used Netgear 834 on ebay which I hope to receive in the next few days.
|
|
|
|
Just received firmware 6.2.16.3 from Speedtouch support so will try it and report back
|
|
|
In reply to:
Just received firmware 6.2.16.3 from Speedtouch support so will try it and report back
How did you get on?
I've just had the timeout problem for the second time so I was also thinking of upgrading my firmware from the current 5 .1 .4 .3 version in an attempt to get rid of the timeout errors as it's annoying.
http://i11.tinypic.com/346pa2c.jpg
|
|
|
By the way where did you get the newest firmware from as I've tried the 'official' SpeedTouch website and only the 5 .1 .4 .3 firmware is available
|
|
|
|
Not convinced one way or the other yet. Connection failed yesterday and couldn't get back on so reverted to BT Voyager again. Back on the Speedtouch today now connected for 9 hours with no problem so far.
6.2.16.3 firmware came from Speedtouch support after reporting the problem in December 2006.
|
|
|
Thanks for the feedback.
You still had the timeout problem even with the newer firmware!
SpeedTouch really need to sort this problem out as quite a few 585 users are being affected now
|
|
|
|
I've changed to the new hardware and noticed this alot less now, but its cause by a drop of around 3-4db. If my connection drops to 4-5dp then my connection will go really slow and eventually disconnect I then noticed it cant reconnect because of:
Error Seconds (Local/Remote): 293 / 0
This will keep counting until I reset my DSL connection. Once I reset I can then connect fine. Don't know if that helps anyone or if anyone knows how to sort out this issue?
|
|
|
yes this could be the cause in the past when my snr margin has simply got too low but not caused a loss of synch it simply kills of the ppp. Curly may also be having this problem as he has a low snr margin.
Andrews & Arnold
atten 48.5 - line dist 1.65 straight - 2.96 actual
|
|
|
In reply to:
Curly may also be having this problem as he has a low snr margin.
Yes this is true.
Through the day my margin is at 6 dB but in the evenings it drops to only 3 or 4 dB.
I have downloaded the SpeedTouch 4.4.2.1 firmware upgrade wizard and will use it the next time I suffer the timeout problem.
|
|
|
I start to get the timeout problem at around 5-6db but I start out at 8db. My connection doesn't last long as my signal is horrible. Every time the phone is in use I cannot connect any more.
I only use my master socket with 1 phone plugged in and the internet with no extensions. This has the BT ADSL Faceplate on it yet every time someone uses the phone I disconnect or just randomly disconnect
Any Ideas?
|
|
|
In reply to:
I start to get the timeout problem at around 5-6db but I start out at 8db
Earlier on this evening, my SNR margin went down to 2 dB as sometimes happens but my router didn't drop the connection and neither did I suffer from the 'idle timeout' problem which was surprising!
In reply to:
I only use my master socket with 1 phone plugged in and the internet with no extensions. This has the BT ADSL Faceplate on it yet every time someone uses the phone I disconnect or just randomly disconnect
Any Ideas?
Sorry I can't help you
Perhaps someone who knows more about broadband fault finding will see this and be able to help.
|
|
|
In reply to:
I only use my master socket with 1 phone plugged in and the internet with no extensions. This has the BT ADSL Faceplate on it yet every time someone uses the phone I disconnect or just randomly disconnect
Remove the ADSL faceplate and connect a new ADSL filter to the test socket and then connect your router to the filter, as well as your phone. That will tell you if the ADSL face plate is faulty.
|
|
|
|
Just to update you on my experience - things seem to have settled down now and I can say that although the idle timeout problem has not totally gone away, the 6.2.16.3 firmware has improved the operation of the St585 so that it stays connected for longer (over a day is good on my line) and also does not suffer the timeout problem as often as it did.
|
|
|
In reply to:
things seem to have settled down now and I can say that although the idle timeout problem has not totally gone away, the 6.2.16.3 firmware has improved the operation of the St585 so that it stays connected for longer (over a day is good on my line) and also does not suffer the timeout problem as often as it did.
It's a little too early to tell for me but so far in just over a day I have not had the timeout problem.
Also my errored seconds count is much reduced!
http://i12.tinypic.com/3zh49qc.jpg
http://i19.tinypic.com/446pzir.jpg
p.s. only 4 errored seconds and the reason why my SNR margin is so low is that in the evenings this always drops to between 3 and 4 dB and recovers back to 6 dB throughout the day.
|
|
|
I have been running the 6.2.16.3 firmware release for 5 days, 0:57:32. The connection hasn't dropped once. I think the problem is fixed
---------------
Work: Zen 8000 Active
Play: UKFSN Home MAX 30
---------------
Edited by Fluff (Sun 08-Apr-07 12:52:14)
|
|
|
In reply to:
I have been running the 6.2.16.3 firmware release for 5 days, 0:57:32. The connection hasn't dropped once. I think the problem is fixed
My connection has been up for over 3 days so it's looking good for me too!
Do you find that the new firmware only shows a very low errored seconds count?
Mines only showing 22 errored seconds after 3 days and over a GB of data downloaded!
On the old 6.1.4.3 firmware, this figure would be very much higher
|
|
|
|
With this firmware though you cant use the DMT tool am i right, so if i bought the ST585 for the purpose of using DMT with it does that mean i'm gonna have a router thats disconnecting all the time cause i'm not using the later firmware which doesn't support DMT?.
|
|
|
Er ... you've already asked that question here.
|
|
|
|
Yeah i guess i have, but i never really got a direct answer, so thought it would be good to ask the other guy about his experiences and if he had to upgrade his firmware to get rid of the idle timeout problem, which means no DMT.
|
|
|
|
I've not had the idle timeout problem since I made the following adjustments to my 585v6 which I came across in another thread on here:
Telnet into the router and do:
env list
which should show a big list of environment variables with SESSIONTIMEOUT in it probably set to 600.
If you then do:
env set var=SESSIONTIMEOUT value=0
saveall
I'm running the 6.1.4.3 firmware and am currently on 13 days of uptime since making this change. Of course, having now posted this the problem will re-occur in the next 5 mins.
|
|
|
In reply to:
env set var=SESSIONTIMEOUT value=0
saveall
I saw that telnet command posted on here a while ago and I also tried it out but the 'idle timeout' problem still came back so I've given up with the 6.1.4.3 firmware now!
Someone said that that particular telnet command is to do with the telnet interface timing out and is nothing to do with the 'idle timeout' problem mentioned in this thread but don't quote me on it as I'm not sure to be honest?
Edited by deleted (Mon 09-Apr-07 17:22:40)
|
|
|
I think the SessionTimeOut Value is for the Telnet Session.
Tim
ZeN & freenetname
ST546v5 on 8 Meg Active
Check my bad boy speeds out on ZeN
Sign up for Latency Monitoring
|
|
|
In reply to:
I think the SessionTimeOut Value is for the Telnet Session
Yes I think so too.
Whatever it's for it didn't fix the 'idle timeout' problem for me
|
|
|
|
It's Telnet time-out. See page 232 of the CLI User Guide, where it quotes this one as an example of the use of the "env" command:
"For infinite TELNET time out, set the value of the variable SESSIONTIMEOUT to
|
|
|
If anyone wants to try the 6.2.16.3 for the speedtouch 585v6 you can download it from here and the firmware release notes in pdf are here
Edited by deleted (Tue 10-Apr-07 07:50:29)
|
|
|
Oh well, I've just been very lucky then. 13 days with no idle-timeout is unheard of for me. I thought this had cracked it, but now I'm just waiting for the inevitable
Thanks for clearing up precisely what that EV affects though.
|
|
|
Thomson ST585v6 HP (BANT-9) looks worrying, what is this product? it starts with a firmware version which DMT does not work on possibly meaning speedtouch are going to phase out routers that support DMT tweaks.
Andrews & Arnold
atten 48.5 - line dist 1.65 straight - 2.96 actual
|
|
|
|
I think the HP stands for High Power and I don't think it's intended for use in the UK.
Harbinger.
|
|
|
interesting
Andrews & Arnold
atten 48.5 - line dist 1.65 straight - 2.96 actual
|
|
|
|
Further reading suggests that it's for markets where the power of the wireless signal isn't as heavily restricted as it is here in the uk. I found on the australian whirlpool forums that they were saying it is identical hardware but just ships with a slightly modified firmware to up the wiress power, I guess it makes sense for them to use the latest available version of the firmware when doing this i.e. 6.2. Why would they release it with a modified older version of the firmware? I think it's fair to expect that all new models will come with 6.2 and upwards versions of the firmware which as we all know too well is not compatible with DMT.
Harbinger.
|
|
|
|
Well I tried the latest firmware and it was fine, until it re-synced , and because I can't tweak the SNR I dropped to 3700ish instead of my usual 5128ish, which for me isn't good enough.
What I have done is go back to 6.1.4.3 and to solve the ide timeout problem I sometimes get i am using some automation software to every 30mins ping a reliable ip, ie ISP or bbc website , then if it fails 3 times it telnets to the router and simulates logging in and doing a system reboot command to reset the router, it will also email me when its done as well. Time will tell if it works, it may need tweaking or I might even be able to trap the error condition on the snmp config options in the automation software.
|
|
|
|
Just out of interest, what automation software are you using?
Harbinger.
|
|
|
|
Software is Automate 6
|